Evinrude V4 Compression Woes

matthew.brown.mls

Recruit
Thread starter
Joined
Sep 15, 2017
Messages
3
Hello,

I have an E140TLCRD (1984 Evinrude 140hp) outboard that's giving me some issues, hoping some wise souls will have some advice for me.

The symtoms - I took my Stratos 1789 F&S out for probably the longest run of the season (45 min @ half throttle) last month, Farthest point from shore, the motor shutdown while the boat was on plane, no warning. Felt like I lost spark on all cylinders at once, the crank spun until it was out of momentum (a second or two). I try and restart, battery is dead. Odd considering I had no issues/hard starts earlier. I swap my main battery for the trolling battery, engine starts up but sounds funny, not horrible, but intermittent whirring. Didn't feel great but got the boat up on plane. Died two more times on the way to the nearest boat launch, but slow stall-out's that were more like loss of fuel symptoms.

I've taken good care of the carbs, and don't suspect fuel issues. Tested the rectifier thinking the sudden loss of power was either shorted rectifier or melted stator, Rectifier tested bad. I bought a new one, and installed it. Checked under flywheel for melted stator - looked ok. Figured I should do a compression test to make sure the powerhead doesn't have any issues - got 115 psi across 3 cylinders, 4th has 0 compression. Not even a little. I removed the cylinder head on the bank with the bad cylinder, I can't tell for sure but I might be missing rings on that piston. The head gasket looked ok. The part of the cylinder walls I can see are smooth, no melted metal on spark plugs, head or top of pistons.

I don't have a water pressure gauge on the outboard, but the tell-tail was squirting the whole trip. I know I need to pull the powerhead, pistons, crank, etc - see what the damage is. Anyone have any theories as to what broke, in what order? I hate fixing symptoms only to find the cause of the symptoms coming back to haunt me. I figure I'll pull apart the water pump as part of the work, see how bad that looks.

Is there a thermal cut-off for this motor, something that would ground out the ignition system if the block gets too hot? I'm guessing my rectifier could have been bad for some time and I may not have known it. The dead battery charged ok (on home charger) and seems fine now.

Thanks for any insight!

- Matt
 

racerone

Honorary Supreme Mariner
Joined
Dec 28, 2013
Messages
40,028
It is a common failure and broken rings happens all the time !-----In my opinion it will happen to all those crossflow engines.
 

interalian

Commander
Joined
Jul 23, 2009
Messages
2,105
No Title

The 0 compression cylinder ate its rings. Not an uncommon problem on these. The other three at 115 are on the low side but that could just be your gauge. You can check the rings on each piston by turning it to the top of the bore and looking down the gap between piston and cylinder, shining a flashlight in. You should be able to see shiny ring all around save for one gap at either 12 or 6 o'clock.

Check the rubber diverters in the waterjacket and look for any corrosion buildup in the cooling passages.

Was the head gasket fully intact?
 

Attachments

  • photo273914.png
    photo273914.png
    144.9 KB · Views: 2
  • photo273915.png
    photo273915.png
    147.5 KB · Views: 2

matthew.brown.mls

Recruit
Thread starter
Joined
Sep 15, 2017
Messages
3
I'm having a hard time seeing the rings on that piston, flashlight in hand - There does seem to be a *lot* of play in the piston, wiggles/clicks when I push it back and forth. I'd be buying pistons if this were a snowmobile motor - not sure how much play is allowable for an outboard of this vintage. I did try sliding a thin piece of paper between the cylinder and the cylinder wall of a 'good' cylinder vs. the zero compression cylinder. Felt like they both hit a stop at the same spot. Maybe one side of the rings on that bad cylinder are frozen in the piston groove? Guess I won't know till I tear it down.

The rubber diverters look ok, I thought the gasket looked pretty good for circa 1984 - Didn't see any trails/marks/evidence of leaks. Running my finger in the bad piston on the top part felt like there was some un-even'ness (vertical scoring). Doesn't seem like enough for 0psi compression test.

Definitely looks like the end of my boating season :-(

Pictures:

https://ibb.co/eRQizQ
https://ibb.co/dQSJYk


- Matt
 

racerone

Honorary Supreme Mariner
Joined
Dec 28, 2013
Messages
40,028
Remove bypass cover on side of block to look at piston rings.
 

interalian

Commander
Joined
Jul 23, 2009
Messages
2,105
I think I see some small dings in the bottom combustion chamber. If there are dings it's from ring pieces coming through. When cold, there's a LOT of play on the pistons in these (I had the same question...).
 
Top