Evinrude 65 Skipping and then falls into neutral

ericinmontana

Recruit
Thread starter
Joined
Jul 30, 2018
Messages
3
Hello all. Just joined this great forum today and I thank you for your time in reading and/or replying.

I have a nice old 48 Hydro Swift with a 65 hp evinrude motor from the early seventies (so I was told). She sat for a year and when I charged up the battery, put on the earmuffs and cranked her up she started perfectly.

When i I took it out on the water however, it started fine, and when I started to cruise up the speed, she started skipping and “single clunking” if that’s a phrase. Almost like it was cutting out power. But then it would run and start fine every time if I backed it off and shut it down. So we just “slow boated around”. Ran perfect slow. Then I cranked it up ever so slightly and it thunked again and then slipped out of gear. Sounds perfect still running. Started every time. But it’s like it’s shlioping back into neutral. I’m trying to post a video of it happening if it will let me.

Much help is appreciated. Thank you kindly. Fresh water lakes only in Montana.
 

jimmbo

Supreme Mariner
Joined
May 24, 2004
Messages
14,699
I watched the video, 2 things come to mind, a worn clutch dog, even though the Hydro-electrics shift real fast they eventually wear, and it is a 72, so that's 46 yrs old.
What oil are you using in the gearcase? the sped was OMC Typc C. renamed in 73 as Premium Blend, and is still marketed by BRP under the same name. 3rd party Type C oils may or may not be compatible with any gearcase that has any electrical components inside.
This might sound insulting but, is the gearcase full? And water free?

Depending on what brand the prop is, it could be a hub problem. A rubber hub rarely sounds like that, but a hub like Mercury flow torq, or a Solas hub kit, or a Turning point hub could under load if it had shattered on an impact.


I like the boat and its markings, the red matches my eyes
 
Last edited:

Faztbullet

Supreme Mariner
Joined
Mar 2, 2008
Messages
15,938
Its a lower unit problem. Sound like either the oil pump is not letting it default into full forward or piston in propshaft is sticky..
 

F_R

Honorary Supreme Mariner
Joined
Jul 7, 2006
Messages
28,226
It sounds like a totally worn out clutch dog and forward gear--very unusual on a hydro-electric unit, but not impossible. That motor was engineered to be fail safe, to default into forward gear in case of failure. So either something is preventing it from going into gear or once it does go into gear it is too worn out to handle the load.

My vote is something is preventing the piston in the oil pump from returning to forward gear. Those motors were very sensitive to microscopic grit in the oil making that piston stick.

Sorry, but lower unit must be totally dis-assembled to fix it.
 

F_R

Honorary Supreme Mariner
Joined
Jul 7, 2006
Messages
28,226
On the other hand, the words "never assume" come to mind. You should always check out the electricals before tearing into the lower unit. There should be zero voltage on the green (neutral) wire when forward button is pushed. For instance, a low voltage leak to the green wire could almost close the neutral flow control valve making it stay almost in neutral. Again, unusual but not impossible.
 

ericinmontana

Recruit
Thread starter
Joined
Jul 30, 2018
Messages
3
Morning all. Thanks for the feedback. I’ll go through each of your responses and see if I can execute testing out or fixing some of this. I’m not a “motor guy” unfortunately but am always sharp to learn new things.

Oilwise, I use AmsOil Dominator. I was told by the previous owner it’s what he’s used for years even though it’s much more expensive. Here’s a picture.

Regarding the motor itself, do you all feel it’s worth fixing since I would have to find someone local and pay them to fix it? Or should I put it on eBay for parts knowing they’re scarce and someone might make some good money selling parts off individually?

Thanks again for for the guidance.
 

Attachments

  • photo297681.jpg
    photo297681.jpg
    704.3 KB · Views: 0
  • photo297681.jpg
    photo297681.jpg
    704.3 KB · Views: 0

racerone

Honorary Supreme Mariner
Joined
Dec 28, 2013
Messages
40,028
Agreed ----sounds like the shift piston is not sliding properly in the bore.------Easy fix for me but finding a shop to tackle that may not be easy in your area.-----Show them some cash I suppose.
 
Top