Engine runs poorly, can't set timing correctly? Lack of power

Webercook

Cadet
Thread starter
Joined
Jul 1, 2011
Messages
10
First, thanks for taking the time to review my concern.

I have a 1991 Baja Islander 225. I got the boat with a bad engine (2 pistons damaged). I rebuilt the engine last spring and it has never run right. Here is the boat information:
Year, Make & Model: 1991 Baja Islander 225
Mercruiser
Outdrive: Alpha 1 Serial# OB887782
Prop: Currently has a 19p (have tried 17 & 21p)
Engine: GM V-8 Small Block 350, 5.7L
Cylinders are 0.030 over
9.5:1 aftermarket pistons (Summit)
Cylinder Heads from GM 305 (raises compression slightly. Est 10:1)
Camshaft 465/488 282/292 (from Summit)
Factory Rockers
Edlebrock Performer Air Gap Aluminum Intake Manifold
Edlebrock Performer Marine Carburetor, I believe its a 600 (new)
Spark Plugs: AC Delco MR43T
Ignition: MSD Ignition box/module
MSD Distributor
MSD Ignition Wires (new)

What it's doing:
At the end of last season, I found that it had low compression on all but 1 cylinder. Removed the heads and found that all of the valve stems were at different heights on the top. Also noticed the #1 and #2 (one on each head) intake valves had been hot and started to suck the valve in (con-caved). Therefore, I replaced the heads this season with a set from a 305 chevy. The valves were lapped, seals replaced and springs replaced with some slightly used Summit racing springs (don't know specifics but was told designed for the cam I have). Did not correct the lack of power. Tried a few different props thinking the 21p was possibly too much. It did run a lot better with a 17p but then was revving too high.

Yesterday, I set timing at 0* and it wouldn't start. Set it to 8*, still no start. Set it to 12* and, while pumping the gas, it might start but run very poorly and won't idle for more than 20 seconds. Advanced timing to approximately 25*, based on timing light adjuster dial cuz I can't see the mark on the flywheel otherwise (Indicator is at 2 o'clock position and mark is somewhere around the 12 o'clock position) it starts, runs and idles well. Under load and WOT, lacking power and pinging (indicating too far advanced). Turn back timing slightly, pinging not as bad, gains power. Turn back more (guessing about 20*) it starts running rough at idle and stalls when put into gear. Can't handle any load. Turn back any more, starts popping/backfiring and wont idle at all (indications of too far retarded).

At first, the timing mark was erratic when checking with the timing light. In the process of elimination, I replaced the MSD Module, distributor, spark plugs and wires. Corrected the erratic timing mark but did not change the timing/running concerns. We also thought the timing mark was off on the balancer thinking the rubber spun. However, I checked for TDC, confirmed timing mark dead on 0*.

I have been running regular fuel and it has been suggested to run premium based on the raised compression. However, we do not believe that this is the cause of the timing concern. It may help with the pinging but will not correct the timing issue. I could be wrong tho.

The fuel is good and clean. The carb was replaced before I got the boat but was never really used after installed. I did go through the carb just to make sure there were no restrictions; it was spotless. The fuel pressure has not been checked but does not appear to be a problem. A quick test using an known good electric pump was attempted and this did not make any difference.

After running the boat on the lake, I idled back down a short channel (about 5-min) and pulled it out of the water. When I pulled the spark plugs, the color was pretty good, a slightly darker golden color. No signs of a lean or rich condition. No excessive smoke from exhaust.

The only thing I can think is that the cam gear is off a tooth. However, most people have told me that it likely wouldn't start or run at all if that was the case. The reason I believe this is due to the amount of advance needed to run the engine. Does 20-30* advanced = 1-tooth off??? My brother and I put the engine together last March. He is a long-time GM technician, very experienced with engines. I am not a top notch tech but I do have quite a bit of experience in this field.

I am planning on working on it this evening. Going to do a quick compression test to see where that's at. I am considering putting it in the water and doing a vacuum test to see what kind of readings I'm getting off the manifold. The main plan for tonight was to pull the timing cover to confirm the cam and crank gears are aligned properly as this is the only thing I can come up with at this point.

I would love to hear some other opinions as to what steps I should take next. I am at a loss.

Thank you for taking the time to review my concern.
 

Bondo

Moderator
Staff member
Joined
Apr 17, 2002
Messages
71,545
Re: Engine runs poorly, can't set timing correctly? Lack of power

Ayuh,.... Welcome Aboard,....

I'd ditch the 305 heads, 'n bolt on a pair of Vortecs....
'n keep the compression ratio, just Under 10:1...
 

Webercook

Cadet
Thread starter
Joined
Jul 1, 2011
Messages
10
Re: Engine runs poorly, can't set timing correctly? Lack of power

Bond-o: Thanks for the welcome! Sorry for the delay in response; busy holiday weekend.

In regards to the heads, I used what I had available to me for free. However, I am keeping an eye out for a deal on a pair of Vortecs.

Update on the concern:

*I tried to keep this short but didn't want to leave out any details.

I have checked the cam and it was on and set to the "0" position. Going down the wrong path but have now eliminated the cam timing as a concern.

(With help) After adjusting the timing and idle air mixture, we were able to get it to idle pretty well at about 12* advanced. Took it out and ran it across the lake a couple times. With the 19p prop, it actually got up on plane very quickly and ran about 46 MPH at 5400 RPM's. No pinging was heard. However, it started stalling when you slowed down. Would restart ok. Now, thinking it was the carb; it was recommended to swap it with a larger Edelbrock 700 (removed from a perfectly running 454).

The next day, I installed the carb, which brought me back to the idle problem. Made some adjustments and was able to get it to idle fairly well again. Prob wasn't a good idea to change props yet (1-thing at a time) but my bro needed the 19 for an emergency service call over the holiday and gave me a 21 stainless. Ran fairly well but power wasn't all there yet. Don't think it was the prop; still need to dial in the carb/timing. I attempted myself but seemed to have trouble. I set the timing to 10* but had to raise the idle substantially. With some assistance, I will try dialing it in this week (with help).

A new symptom: while idling through some no-wake zones (the entire Fox Lake after the fireworks), it would idle fine for a few min, then it would almost stall out then come back up and idle ok for a few more min. Did that the entire time.

I will check frequently for any advice you may have and provide an update later this week.

Thanks!
 

Webercook

Cadet
Thread starter
Joined
Jul 1, 2011
Messages
10
Re: Engine idles poorly, can't set timing correctly? Lack of power

Re: Engine idles poorly, can't set timing correctly? Lack of power

Forgot to mention, I put 15-gallons of premium fuel this time. Added to about 15-gal of regular.
 

Bondo

Moderator
Staff member
Joined
Apr 17, 2002
Messages
71,545
Re: Engine idles poorly, can't set timing correctly? Lack of power

Re: Engine idles poorly, can't set timing correctly? Lack of power

Ayuh,... I think it's a fuel/ carb issue...

The 600 Edlebrock is the Right carb for a 350,...
750 is Too Big... it needs more vacuum at idle, 'n yer cam is already abit tall...

Is the hull's Fuel Tank willingly giving up it's cargo,..??
Fuel Filters Clean,..??

Ya really oughta ditch them heads,...
Even the "HotRodders" don't use that lame trick...
 

Webercook

Cadet
Thread starter
Joined
Jul 1, 2011
Messages
10
Re: Engine runs poorly, can't set timing correctly? Lack of power

Bond-o,

Thanks for the additional input. I promise I will ditch the 305 heads as soon as I find a good deal on a set of replacements (and get the cash together). They are all I have available for the time being. If you think they are part of the problem, I will put that high on the priority list.

The fuel filter was changed in the process of elimination as well as opening up the carb and confirming it was clean. I am planning on going back to the 600 carb based on your advise and the fact that the 750 didn't change anything.

For Thursday's diag:
Check vacuum pressure
Check for vacuum leaks
Check fuel pressure
Swap carbs back
Check fuel tank ventilation

Thanks again, should have more info Friday.
 

Webercook

Cadet
Thread starter
Joined
Jul 1, 2011
Messages
10
Re: Engine idles poorly, can't set timing correctly? Lack of power

Re: Engine idles poorly, can't set timing correctly? Lack of power

Bond-o, you were correct about the problem being fue/carb related. I took off the 750 and installed an OEM 4bbl carb. After getting some fuel pumped into it, the engine starteed right up and purred like a kitten. Got up on plane quickly and ran accross Grass Lake. The boat was running about 53 mph @ 4700 rpm's. The only thing I need to do now is replace the starter. My brother killed it with all the cranking; Arrgghh! Oh well.

Just want to thank you again for your input, Bond-o. And don't worry, I'm working on getting rid of those 305 heads. :)
 

Bondo

Moderator
Staff member
Joined
Apr 17, 2002
Messages
71,545
Re: Engine idles poorly, can't set timing correctly? Lack of power

Re: Engine idles poorly, can't set timing correctly? Lack of power

Bond-o, you were correct about the problem being fue/carb related. I took off the 750 and installed an OEM 4bbl carb. After getting some fuel pumped into it, the engine starteed right up and purred like a kitten. Got up on plane quickly and ran accross Grass Lake. The boat was running about 53 mph @ 4700 rpm's. The only thing I need to do now is replace the starter. My brother killed it with all the cranking; Arrgghh! Oh well.

Just want to thank you again for your input, Bond-o. And don't worry, I'm working on getting rid of those 305 heads. :)

Ayuh,... Good Luck with 'er...
 

John_S

Rear Admiral
Joined
Jun 21, 2004
Messages
4,269
Re: Engine idles poorly, can't set timing correctly? Lack of power

Re: Engine idles poorly, can't set timing correctly? Lack of power

I'm not sure what pistons you have (9.5:1?), but if flat top with valve relief, you are probably running high compression for a boat. I can't remember if 305 heads are 62cc or 58cc. Going to the 64cc vortec will help some, but if flat-top piston, go with a thick head gaskit to compensate a little more.
 

Webercook

Cadet
Thread starter
Joined
Jul 1, 2011
Messages
10
Re: Engine idles poorly, can't set timing correctly? Lack of power

Re: Engine idles poorly, can't set timing correctly? Lack of power

I'm not sure what pistons you have (9.5:1?), but if flat top with valve relief, you are probably running high compression for a boat.

They are the 9-1/2:1 falt top with valve relief.

I am looking around for a decent set of vortec heads. A freind mentioned getting a set of dart(?) heads. Not sure about the cc of those.

Thanks for the input.

By the way, the boat ran fantastic all weekend!
 

winterfunguy

Seaman
Joined
Jun 15, 2011
Messages
54
Re: Engine idles poorly, can't set timing correctly? Lack of power

Re: Engine idles poorly, can't set timing correctly? Lack of power

Be extra careful running that kind of compression on a marine engine and definately run only premium fuel. To put it in laymans terms a marine engine is under load the entire time it is running...sort of like running an engine on a dyno its entire life unlike an automobile that can roll and significantly drop the engine load as the vehicle reaches cruising speeds. The problem is that once spark knock is heard in an engine it has already started doing damage and damage happens very quickly in a marine setup...hence your burned and sunk valves due to excessive combustion chamber temps. I am running a similar setup to you with vortex heads and a Lunati Voodoo102 cam with a 750 454 carb and can only run premium at 9.5:1 due to the increasing concentrations of ethenol. If your ignition setup is not the marine version you WILL burn your engine down...the automotive timing curve in no way resembles that of a marine engines.
 

Webercook

Cadet
Thread starter
Joined
Jul 1, 2011
Messages
10
Re: Engine idles poorly, can't set timing correctly? Lack of power

Re: Engine idles poorly, can't set timing correctly? Lack of power

Winterfunguy: Thanks for the additional information. I have been running an automotive MSD distributor. I was under the impression that the difference was mainly for sealing out moisture and keeping sparks in (due to being in an enclosed engine compartment). I was not aware that the timing curve was different. I guess that will get changed ASAP. Due to the raised compression, I have been running premium fuel. The boat has been running great so far.
 

winterfunguy

Seaman
Joined
Jun 15, 2011
Messages
54
Re: Engine idles poorly, can't set timing correctly? Lack of power

Re: Engine idles poorly, can't set timing correctly? Lack of power

The distributor should be ok if you are using your thunderbolt ignition module. MSD makes a marine ignition similar to the 6AL used for automotive apps, I believe the model is the 6M??? If you are using a in cap coil distributor contact MSD and see what they recomend for your particular distributor to get a marine timing curve.
 

Webercook

Cadet
Thread starter
Joined
Jul 1, 2011
Messages
10
Re: Engine idles poorly, can't set timing correctly? Lack of power

Re: Engine idles poorly, can't set timing correctly? Lack of power

I have the MSD module (red box; If I'm not mistaking, the marine MSD module is blue), I think it is the 6AL, and an external coil (cylinder shape separate from the distributor). I will confirm the module model this weekend when I take the boat out again but pretty sure its the 6AL.
 

winterfunguy

Seaman
Joined
Jun 15, 2011
Messages
54
Re: Engine idles poorly, can't set timing correctly? Lack of power

Re: Engine idles poorly, can't set timing correctly? Lack of power

In my personal experience the mad ignition systems are not as good or reliable as the crane ignitions, they are black and have 6 built in timing curves and a built in rev limiter that is adjustable with a small screwdriver where as the msd units require you to purchase the individual chips. Keep the distributor you are running it will be fine, just get rid of the ignition controller. Definately try to get the crane controller though.
 

DarrinT

Petty Officer 2nd Class
Joined
Aug 7, 2008
Messages
160
Re: Engine runs poorly, can't set timing correctly? Lack of power

Check the fuel lines especially in the tank(s)

Buddy of mine had the exact same symptoms and it turned out to be a crack in the line in the tank that would suck air under high fuel flow conditions stalling the engine. The crack would then close and it would start right up!!!!

Made him bonkers for two seasons before he found the flaw beacuse with a full tank the crack was under the fuel so this problem was only intermittent under the condition of lowish fuel and WOT
 
Top