Desulphator anyone had any success..??

fucawi

Banned
Thread starter
Joined
May 18, 2011
Messages
1,039
Personaly always thought these were a waste of time ...If a long slow charge say 3 weeks cannot bring it back then its scrap......Also was taught that dirty DC ie half wave rectified AC was the best for charging ...many moons ago... the peak of the cycle would be well over the average 14.4v of the charged battery
Now what these sulphators do is to charge two capacitors to battery volts then the eletronics switches them from parallel to series across the battery giving a 24v pulse. The charger is connected so if the battery recovers it can charge it .....

Problem is as I see it if you have a knackerd battery and try the sulphator and it recovers you dont know if it would have recovered with just a long connection to the charger ......and if you try the charger for 3 weeks and then the sulphator how do you know it would not have recovered in another week.....

I am persuading myself again its a waste of time !!!!

But what if you use the sulphator every time you charge the battery from new ...???
 

TerryMSU

Senior Chief Petty Officer
Joined
Jul 31, 2007
Messages
743
Re: Desulphator anyone had any success..??

I definately have seen success. A co-worker was having difficulties with an optima battery that he had left in a car over the winter without running it, or charging the battery. He had tried the long connection to the battery and no luck. Then he tried the desulfate function on a Black and Decker brand charger. It took a couple of cycles thru the desulfator (with, if memory serves correctly, alternating cycles of normal charging), but the battery now works just fine and has for about 6 months thru the summer. By the way, the battery was so dead before, that he had to go back to an old fashioned charger to get it to start to come back up. (The Black and Decker said it was bad and would not even try to charge it.) He also tried the same action on a more traditional battery and had similar results. You do not use the desulfate function every time, only when your battery hits the dust. In any case, desulfation can and does work, although it may take some persistance. Besides, the desulfation function is built in to many battery chargers at a miminal cost hit. If anyone has any questions, send me a PM and I can get the exact specific details of how he did the de-sulfation process. I would ask him now, but we are on Christmas break now, so I won't see him until after January 1. Which reminds me, "Merry Christmas" to all. If you find the term Christmas offensive, please insert your own holiday instead.

TerryMSU
 

DianneB

Petty Officer 1st Class
Joined
Feb 8, 2010
Messages
303
Re: Desulphator anyone had any success..??

Many years ago Kester (the solder people) made a de-sulphate solution that you simply poured into each battery cell and it worked like gang-busters. Unfortunately it disappeared as quickly as it appeared and I suspect the battery manufacturers had something to do with its disappearance.

I have successfully de-sulphated batteries in the lab but ONLY batteries where you can access each cell individually. On individual cells the success rate is 90% or better. On batteries where you can only access the 12 volt terminals (and not the individual cells) the success rate is pretty small, less than 10%.

The principle behind breaking down sulphate is to use as much voltage as you have to to get a small current flow and maintain the small current for a long period of time. As the sulphate breaks down, the current can not be allowed to rise or it will destroy the battery. I don't use a commercial de-sulphater but a lab power supply where I can limit the current independent of the voltage.

The batteries I deal with most often are 2.5 A-Hr gell cells, 2.2 volts each, that are used for emergency lighting. If a cell is heavily sulphated, it may take 10 to 20 volts to get a current for of 0.05 Amperes through a 2.2 volt cell and I will set the current limit to 0.5 A. As/if the cell recovers, the voltage across the cell with drop toward 2.2 volts and the current will increase. The charging/recovery will be stopped when the cell is fully charged.

I have used the same process on 12 volt batteries where the individual cells are not accessible but it can take quite a high voltage to get the initial current flow and in the process of recovering one cell, the other cells can be badly over-charged which presents an extreme hazard in that the other cells will be venting hydrogen which is highly explosive.

Bottom line is that most people don't have access to the equipment to de-sulphate this way nor the resources to deal with explosive gases so YES, batteries can be de-sulphated but it is probably not worth the risk for the small savings.
 
Top