Clutch Dog Opinion - Johnson 90hp

whiteoak11

Recruit
Thread starter
Joined
Jun 25, 2011
Messages
3
I've searched extensively and tried to find comparison examples of worn clutch dogs. Most tend to be in much worse shape than what I've got. When i tore this outboard open, I expected to find a smoking gun and I don't think I have.

I've got a textbook case of "hitting a stump". I tore the lower unit down once before, saw that all the gears and clutch dog looked good (in my uneducated opinion) and so I decided to put things all back together and adjust linkage. I tightened the shift linkage to the point that the boat doesn't want to come out of forward gear when you shift back to neutral...as a test. Still "hitting a stump". I tore it back down last night and I still don't feel like the clutch dog or gears are worn enough to warrant it jumping a tooth. Furthermore, when I first shift into gear, it jumps right in....no grinding. I'd figure that if the teeth were worn down enough to matter that it would fight against going into gear.

Here are pictures of my dog/forward gear. Guidance would be much appreciated.

 

Joe Reeves

Supreme Mariner
Joined
Feb 24, 2002
Messages
13,262
Engine model number?

Your explanation indeed describes a lower init that is jumping out of and back into gear.

From what I can see of the pictures, the edge of those lobes (dog & gear) don't really look that bad, I've seen a lot worse. However,up close and personally handling those parts might reveal a different story. (A reliable machine shop could clean them up)

Has this unit performed okay in the past...OR... is this unit new to you and clunking out and in since you got it?

The proper positioning of the dog should be that the "score lines" on the face of the clutch dog lobes face the forward gear. Notice that the prop-shaft splines DO NOT extend on one set of the lobes... those spineless lobes are to face the reverse gear.

On some units, it is possible to install the clutch dog backwards... should one accidentally do this, the unit would jump out of gear even if everything was brand new.
 

F_R

Honorary Supreme Mariner
Joined
Jul 7, 2006
Messages
28,226
I agree, they don't look that bad to me. I probably would have reinstalled them myself. But then the mystery remains, what is causing the log sensation?
 

oldboat1

Fleet Admiral
Joined
Apr 3, 2002
Messages
9,612
Was there any other testing done? Ignition testing? Post your model number, as requested above, and some history.
 

Bosunsmate

Admiral
Joined
Apr 7, 2012
Messages
6,135
How do your driveshaft splines look?
Did you notice any metal in your LU?
Try running the engine for ten seconds or so without the LU on just to double check the problem isnt up there. You can always hook a hose to the intake tube if you want to run it for longer
 

whiteoak11

Recruit
Thread starter
Joined
Jun 25, 2011
Messages
3
Model: VJ90TLESB

Has this unit performed okay in the past...OR... is this unit new to you and clunking out and in since you got it?
It started doing this last year but I've just gotten around to messing with it this year. The only time that anybody (that I know of) has been in the lower unit has been me and only after it started "stump thumping". I did make sure that the clutch dog was installed in the correct direction when I put it all back together the first time and also verified when I disassembled.

Was there any other testing done? Ignition testing? Post your model number, as requested above, and some history.
I tested good spark at each plug. Re-gapped everything. Compression test on all cylinders and all were ~120psi. Swapped power packs out with no change. Is there something else I should do? The ignition route is something I was curious about. The "thump" tend to occur on a pretty consistent basis depending on what rpm the boat is running at. For example, running at 3,000rpm the thump would occur every ~12 seconds. At 4000rpm, it would occur every ~6 seconds. And so on. I did some experimenting but didn't write the exact timing down but you get the point. I didn't know what the gear ratio was but was going to attempt to see if it was a direct correlation with RPM and "THUMP".

How do your driveshaft splines look?
Did you notice any metal in your LU?
All gears, splines, etc in the motor are basically in perfect shape. No wear or chipped teeth anywhere. When I first tore the lower unit apart, I was very careful to check for metal shavings/chunks and there was none.
 
Last edited:

Joe Reeves

Supreme Mariner
Joined
Feb 24, 2002
Messages
13,262
1990 90hp Johnson
Your explanation (post #6), especially stating the increase of the thumps as the rpms increase pinpoints (for me) the cause as a lower unit jumping out of and back into gear. However, in revisiting the pictures (enlarged), I still cannot see why that unit would be encountering that problem.

Is there anything missing in that lower unit that would create a distance problem between the dog and gear shift lobes? If not, when you adjusted the shift so that the dog favored forward gear, you state... (" I tightened the shift linkage to the point that the boat doesn't want to come out of forward gear when you shift back to neutral...as a test."). this should have the shfter dog pressed right up against forward gear so as if you turned the propeller with your hand, you would feel an absolute and definite resistance to turning the propeller. If this resistance existed, it's unlikely that anything is missing.

In looking thru the 190 90hp OMC parts book to refresh my memory, I don't see anything that could be missing without having the unit turn into a mass of aluminum & steel particles within a short run... besides you indicated that it ran okay year before last, then last year this problem started, and you just got around to looking at it this year.... and no one has taken a wrench to it but yourself.

One thing..... Many boaters think that by shifting slowly, they are taking it easy on the engine... nothing is further from the truth. The unit MUST be snapped into gear as quick as possible to eliminate the possible clicking of the shifting lobe edges.

Frankly, in again looking at the shifter dog and gears you inserted, if it were me, I'd be tempted to throw a new shifter dog in there just to see what would happen. It is a puzzling mystery... shouldn't be happening.
 

whiteoak11

Recruit
Thread starter
Joined
Jun 25, 2011
Messages
3
Joe, thank you very much for all the feedback. I'll go ahead and get a new dog. I'm also going to measure the distance that the shifter moves up when I shift it into forward before I put the lower unit back together. I'm going to make sure the same travel happens up where the linkage connects to the shifter cable and whatnot. For some reason, it seems like there's more travel available at the dog/gear connection than what occurs at the top of the shift rod when all is buttoned up.
 

Joe Reeves

Supreme Mariner
Joined
Feb 24, 2002
Messages
13,262
Joe, thank you very much for all the feedback. I'll go ahead and get a new dog. I'm also going to measure the distance that the shifter moves up when I shift it into forward before I put the lower unit back together. I'm going to make sure the same travel happens up where the linkage connects to the shifter cable and whatnot. For some reason, it seems like there's more travel available at the dog/gear connection than what occurs at the top of the shift rod when all is buttoned up.

That's due to the leverage that's created by the linkage in the lower unit..... normal.
 
Top