Charger failure or battery?

Kswan

Recruit
Thread starter
Joined
Aug 18, 2012
Messages
2
I have a Lund 3 bank charger of which I use 2 banks for the 24v system trolling motor batteries. Batteries are 2 years old but charger is 2001. Found 1 battery is dead and 1 charger bank will not light. Does this imply my charger needs to be replaced? Can a battery cook a charger or is it more likely the charger cooked the battery? Appreciate any feedback.
 
Joined
Feb 17, 2012
Messages
2,906
Re: Charger failure or battery?

battery charger will not light if the battery is bad so its hard to say with out trying the charger on a diffrent battery. a battery shouldnt be able to damadge a charger and a good charger should ruin a battery. try swapping the batterys around and see what happens if the charger still refuses to charge it may be a bad charger. either way the battery is proberly done and needs replacing
 

Jlawsen

Master Chief Petty Officer
Joined
Apr 22, 2012
Messages
810
Re: Charger failure or battery?

Ah, the two year old battery syndrome. LOL.. Maybe I can help. Batteries that are used for trolling motors, etc., tend to last only about two years. The major cause is the repeated discharging and charging. Just recently I noticed battery manufacturers listing charge cycle ratings in their specs. I'm not sure if this is a requirement now or a way of informing the buyer what to expect and help them understand the warranty better.

Anyway, a battery can only withstand a certain number of charge cycles and after that they're gone. There is a logical mechanical explanation for this but I won't bore you with all that gobbly gook. Just realize that the better the batteries internal components the more charge cycles it can withstand.

With your onboard charger you're probably pugging it in when you get home and leaving it on to float the battery. That counts as one charge cycle. If you're battery is rated for 180 charge cycles (a good marine battery) that's the manufacturers safe estimate of how many times you can do that before the battery fails to charge. Some get less and some get more mostly dependent on the abuse the battery gets in the boat.

So what's bad, the charger or the battery. The battery, the charger will not charge or indicate a charge cycle has begun unless the battery is capable of accepting a charge.

Moral of the story, replace your batteries bi-annually. It's part of owning a boat.
 

Kswan

Recruit
Thread starter
Joined
Aug 18, 2012
Messages
2
Re: Charger failure or battery?

Thanks everyone. I did replace both batteries and my #2 bank is not lighting. Just wasn't sure if there may be a fuse (Wishful thinking perhaps) or if I was looking at replacing the charger. The bad battery from that connection was noticeably bad when I removed it...concave on both ends and battery was high quality brand. I've seen my batteries wear at different levels over the years and assuming quality and manufacturing locations play into price (sometiimes :) I have not always replaced in 2 years as charge cycles and use play key factors. But I had a similar situation years back with a classic car and it's battery. I replaced the battery and through out the charger but I never understood where the failure actually occurred. Chicken or the egg concept I guess with batteries and chargers overall.

Just trying to reach out before accepting purchasing another charger... Thanks again.
 
Top