93 Evinrude 120hp engine knock

clclowers

Recruit
Thread starter
Joined
Aug 31, 2017
Messages
3
Hello all, I've used this forum to discover trouble shooting tips for my boat in the past, but I'm having an issue which led me to become a member and start a new topic, so I could gather some guidance. Here goes.....

I have a 93 Lowe 2200 deck boat with a 120hp Evinrude engine (Model# VE120TLET). I took a group of guys skiing and wake boarding this past June and my engine seemed to develop a knock. It's a rotational noise, meaning it has a rhythm that's consistent with the RPMs. The noise is present whether on plane or at idle. Once I noticed it we stopped pulling skiers and headed back to the boat ramp. I wanted to see if it was down on power, so I opened the throttle up as we headed towards the boat ramp and everything seemed normal, except for the knock.

I live a little over an hour away from the lake where the boat is kept and have had a crazy busy summer, so this weekend is the first chance I'll have to dig into the problem. I'm reaching out to anyone that reads this post to offer some trouble shooting advice, so when I'm working on the boat this weekend, I'm not wasting my efforts. I'm confident in my mechanical skills, but don't have much experience with marine engines.

I plan to first identify where the noise is coming from, lower unit or engine. My hunch is the engine. Then I plan to run a compression test. Beyond that, I don't know. It depends on what I find out along the way. My guess is I'll have to start disassembling things to do some "exploratory surgery."

Please let me know any tests I should perform that might lead me to my problem before I start taking things apart.

Thanks in advance!
 

Joe Reeves

Supreme Mariner
Joined
Feb 24, 2002
Messages
13,262
Let us know what the compression psi is on all the individual cylinders... also the appearance of the spark plugs as you remove them and from what cylinder.

(Piston Play Check)
(J. Reeves)

This procedure will tell you if there is any wear or play in the Wrist Pin, Wrist Pin Bearing, or Connecting Rod to Crankshaft area.

Remove the spark plugs. Insert a screwdriver, dowel, punch, or some object of your choice through the s/plug hole and into the cylinder/piston area. Hold the tool lightly against the top of the piston. Turn the flywheel by hand, bringing the piston up to top dead center, then continue turning the flywheel to pull the piston down about a inch..... all the while holding the tool lightly against the piston top.

Now, at the point whereas the piston has been dropped down about a inch, grab the flywheel and hold it firmly. Now, push that tool solidly and firmly against the piston top.

If the piston moves without moving the flywheel, there is a problem (wear, play, clearance, etc) somewhere with the items mention in the first sentence. Be sure to check all of the pistons/cylinders.
*******************************
Also.... check the gear-lube for metal filings, actually chips. A chipped gear tooth would have it's sound travel up the drive-shaft and sound like it's coming from the power-head. You need a mechanics stethoscope to determine the noise location.
 

clclowers

Recruit
Thread starter
Joined
Aug 31, 2017
Messages
3
Copy that. I'll be at the lake on Sunday and wifi/cell service is sketchy, so I'll report my findings as soon as I can.
 

interalian

Commander
Joined
Jul 23, 2009
Messages
2,105
An additional test can be done with the motor running. Disconnect the plug wires one at a time and see if the sound changes. Use heavy gloves and well insulated pliers.

Also, a mechanic's stethoscope can be used, touching various parts of the motor while running to listen for the noise, trying to pinpoint it. Watch for moving parts.
 

Faztbullet

Supreme Mariner
Joined
Mar 2, 2008
Messages
15,938
Check the gear oil for shavings/chips as could have spit a tooth.....
 

clclowers

Recruit
Thread starter
Joined
Aug 31, 2017
Messages
3
Sorry for the delayed update on this thread, but I definitely have some things to report. First off, thank you for all the advice. It helped me pinpoint my problem much quicker. Here's what went down....

I hooked the motor up to the garden hose and fired it up so I could use the stethoscope to locate the source of the knocking noise. The noise was not present, but I made sure and touched different points of each cylinder to see if there were any inconsistencies. Everything sounded great. I moved to the lower unit and listened in neutral, forward and reverse. All I heard was the sound of moving parts. Nothing that seemed out of the ordinary or even resembled the sound I was hearing last time I had the boat on the water.

I decided I needed to put the boat on the water to put the motor under a load to try to duplicate the noise. Once it was in the water the noise was back. I was able to determine that the noise is definitely coming from the lower unit. In neutral the motor sounds great. In reverse the noise is present, but nothing like when the boat is in forward. I putted around a little bit to try different things to gather more info and see if there was anything that made the noise louder or quieter. There was really nothing more than can be expected. When the RPM's go up, the noise gets louder.

I brought the boat back up to the driveway and pulled the plug on the lower unit. Rather than having metal shavings on the magnets, there were metal chunks. I tried uploading a picture, but am experiencing some technical difficulties. Both the top and bottom plug were full. No water came out when I initially pulled the plug, but I drained the oil into a clear container and left it in the shop to see if any water would separate out before I get back down to the lake. I'm assuming if there was water, the oil and water would still be pretty emulsified from running the boat.

My assumption is I need to rebuild the lower unit. I'm sure it's something I can do, but I'm hesitant to start the project unless I have all the parts on hand and I know I'll have a day or two to work without interruptions. I'm afraid of having everything torn apart, then having to go home and not return for a couple weeks. I have a few questions for you guys that will help me make a decision on what to do.

Are there any special tools required for disassembly or reassembly?

Is there a market for rebuilt lower units? If the cost is right, it might be easier just to swap them out.

Do you guys have a ballpark price of what a person usually spends to get a lower unit rebuilt? I'm not looking for a detailed quote, just a ballpark figure.

Should I be looking for what caused the issue, or is this something a rebuild will resolve because everything is isolated in the lower unit.

Again, all your input is greatly appreciated!
 

racerone

Honorary Supreme Mariner
Joined
Dec 28, 2013
Messages
40,028
You will likely need gears and they are big money.----Pinion will need to be shimmed.------Look for a used / inspected lower unit.----Or perhaps look for a new SEI unit as they are cost effective, but I am not sure of their quality,
 
Top