'87 Evinrude 20hp: low, but equal, compression after head gasket replacement

one6gauge

Recruit
Thread starter
Joined
Jun 10, 2015
Messages
5
1987 Evinrude 20 hp model#E20CRCUR

Back story:
This is my first outboard, and while I am not a mechanic, I have done a lot of work on cars. I bought an impeller for routine maintenance. While out fishing a few weeks ago, my fishing partner broke the pawls on the rope start. When we got home early, I started on replacing the impeller. Bad idea, since I couldn't test the motor to make sure everything worked. Well, i didn't get the water tube lined up correctly putting the lower unit back on. So, after I finally recieved the pawls and springs a week later, I put them on and tested that they were catching the flywheel, completely forgetting that I hadn't tested the water pump yet. Yep, you guessed it, I didn't notice the lack of tell-tale and we overheated.

The problem:
I overheated the motor. The engine didn't seize, but the top cylinder has some scoring by the exhaust port. Testing the compression cold (since it wouldn't start), I got about 10 psi in both cylinders. I bought a new head gasket, exhaust cover gaskets, cylinder head cover gasket, and bypass cover gasket (not yet installed), and thermostat. After installing all but the bypass cover gasket, I got 45 psi in both cylinders.

The question(s):
I'm going to replace the bypass cover gasket this weekend, but if that doesn't do it, what's next? Would scoring on one of the cylinders cause the compression to be identically low? Seems to me like that would cause only the top to have low psi. Are the rings just shot from overheating? Can I just replace the rings on both, or would I need to replace the top piston as well? How much scoring can be there before the cylinders need to be bored? Should I just part it out and move on?

Thanks in advance for any help. I tried to upload pictures through the exhaust ports, but the site won't let me.
 

flyingscott

Fleet Admiral
Joined
Apr 8, 2014
Messages
8,348
What was the compression before you replaced the head gasket. Get a different gauge and retest.
 

one6gauge

Recruit
Thread starter
Joined
Jun 10, 2015
Messages
5
When I first got the motor, the compression was about 115. After the overheating, it was about 10 psi. I will try a different gauge. I forgot to mention last night that it won't start.

I forgot to mention that after taking off the header, I sanded it down using the plate glass figure 8 method. There was one high spot that I eventually got down to where a .003 feeler gauge wouldn't get through, but I could still get a .0015 feeler through. Take it off and get it all the way flat? I also didn't put any form of gasket sealer on.
 

one6gauge

Recruit
Thread starter
Joined
Jun 10, 2015
Messages
5
Here are some pictures of of the top cylinder through the exhaust port.
 

racerone

Honorary Supreme Mariner
Joined
Dec 28, 2013
Messages
40,028
Motor needs to come apart.---------It will not repair itself with more running !!
 

James R

Commander
Joined
Feb 1, 2007
Messages
2,681
Racerone is very correct. If you like the motor and it is in generally good condition rebuild it. Comps should be up around 120 on that motor. Wont run as is.
 

one6gauge

Recruit
Thread starter
Joined
Jun 10, 2015
Messages
5
Motor needs to come apart.---------It will not repair itself with more running !!
I appreciate that you took the time to comment, but that really doesn't answer my questions. My questions are how I should rebuild it (leave the cylinder vs honing vs boring), and what might cause the both cylinders to have the same compression when only one is scored.
 

one6gauge

Recruit
Thread starter
Joined
Jun 10, 2015
Messages
5
Racerone is very correct. If you like the motor and it is in generally good condition rebuild it. Comps should be up around 120 on that motor. Wont run as is.
Thanks James, I only have $800 into the boat, trailer, motor, and trolling motor, and seeing how a replacement is nearly that amount, I'd like to rebuild it. The only reason I tried to start it was that I didn't believe the rented compression gauge. It just seemed odd that after replacing the head gasket the compression would remain identically low in both cylinders (wishful thinking that the compression was actually 115 in both again and not 45 in both).
 

racerone

Honorary Supreme Mariner
Joined
Dec 28, 2013
Messages
40,028
No decisions can be made until this motor is apart !!--------Not sure what your mechanical expertise is either.
 
Top