My control box broke inside. I have replaced the broken bolt and put it back together since then it won't go forward. It will go in reverse and nuetral and sometimes when control is pushed forward the prop will spin backward, but usually nothing.
If you put a new #67 interlock pin in and did it right, everything should work. Any chance you swapped the throttle and shift cables? Does the motor go into forward/neutral/reverse if you take the cable off the motor? (Turn the prop while shifting so the shift dogs don't jam.)
I've seen the #20 bent when the interlock breaks. Check it isn't bent and interfering with the mechanism.