5 Fresh Water Pumps Why?

Bob Lucas

Recruit
Thread starter
Joined
Apr 22, 2009
Messages
3
5 Fresh Water Pumps Why?


I have gone through 5 fresh water pumps on my 3 year old boat.

They were a mix of FLO-JET and PAR-MAX. models 4405-143 and 2.9

Problems have been a mix of pressure switches and some motor failures.

The most recent lasted less than a day before the pressure switch quit.

I am reluctant to install another until I figure out what is causing the problems.

A couple of facts:

The pump is housed in a dry environment. Never a sign of corrosion.

The pumps have a screened inlet ? nothing has ever been found on
the screen.

Wiring to the pump is through a switch on console.

We only turn the switch on when using the fresh water.

Line voltage reads ~~~ 12.4v.

The circuit breaker has never tripped.


Any suggestions?

Thanks,
Bob Lucas
 

Splat

Lieutenant
Joined
Jul 20, 2008
Messages
1,366
Re: 5 Fresh Water Pumps Why?

I'll have to think about this one for a little bit. The only thing that comes to mind immediatly is a freezing issue, or perhaps a low line voltage/brownout problem(when you change the operating voltage, or frequincy of it the internal resistance of the motor changes and it gets hot and can burn out), but that doesn't explain the pressure switches.

Are you sure they aren't runnign dry?

Do the motors have a electrical smell?

Bill
 

Silvertip

Honorary Supreme Mariner
Joined
Sep 22, 2003
Messages
28,772
Re: 5 Fresh Water Pumps Why?

Water systems that don't have an accummulator (essentially a captive air tank) on them means the motor runs more than it has to or short cycles. If the system has an accummulator it may be nearly full of water and needs to be drained. A slight drip at a fixture means the pump can short cycle. The pump motor and the pressure switch are related but only in the sense that if the switch sticks the motor can run continuously. Perhaps the pump(s) you are using a simply not up to the task and the switches are not able to handle the current demands of the pump.
 

Woodnaut

Chief Petty Officer
Joined
Jul 4, 2007
Messages
634
Re: 5 Fresh Water Pumps Why?

Water systems that don't have an accummulator (essentially a captive air tank) on them means the motor runs more than it has to or short cycles...

...A slight drip at a fixture means the pump can short cycle...

The starting current on any motor is higher than the running current. Sometimes current inrush can be significant and generate significant heat as well. Heat (and corrosion) kill electric motors. Just a thought.
 

Bob Lucas

Recruit
Thread starter
Joined
Apr 22, 2009
Messages
3
Re: 5 Fresh Water Pumps Why?

Not a running dry issue. The supply tank outlet is at the same level as the pump suction. And there is no smell (let the smoke out) odor from the motor.

Any test for the voltage issue mentioned above?

Thanks for the input.

Bob L.
 

Silvertip

Honorary Supreme Mariner
Joined
Sep 22, 2003
Messages
28,772
Re: 5 Fresh Water Pumps Why?

Woodnaut wasn't presenting a "voltage issue" but rather a "current issue". Perhaps the plumbing attachment to the pump is distorting the pump putting the motor in a bind. A motor that is binding can draw high current and drastically shorten it's life. The same holds true about running and starting against head pressure. What pressure is the pressure switch set for?
 

Bob Lucas

Recruit
Thread starter
Joined
Apr 22, 2009
Messages
3
Re: 5 Fresh Water Pumps Why?

Just 13 gal of water from bottom of tank to pump feed. Pressure switches set to mid range ~~~25psi.
Tell me more about a currnet issue. Obviously something not detected with a test light or volt meter.
Looked back at the pump's history and most were motor failure.
Any thoughts about installing a quality in line pressure switch and bypassing the pump switch?

Driving me crazy. Tomorrow I'm going to call a number of Hurricane dealers and try to speak with the service managers. My dealer changes managers semi annually and they are ?clueless. Especially now that they are no longer warranty responsible.
 

Silvertip

Honorary Supreme Mariner
Joined
Sep 22, 2003
Messages
28,772
Re: 5 Fresh Water Pumps Why?

Current and voltage are two different electrical characteristics that have been described and discussed at great length on this forum so I won't get into that other than to provide a comparison. High current devices are motors (pumps, engine starter, heaters, etc). Low current devices are fish finders, LED lights, gauges, etc). Current is specified as AMPERES or AMPS. To measure it you need an amp meter (ammeter) which installs in series with the feed to a device. Voltage on the other hand is measured across the feed and ground wires. If a motor is drawing too much current (more than its normal running current) it will typically blow the fuse or trip the circuit breaker for that circuit. But if the fuse is rated (as an example) 15 amps and the motor specs say 10 amps max, the fuse may not blow but the motor may be drawing its maximum current all of the time. Motors are not designed to run that way. As the motor starts up it draws it's maximum current and as it spins up, current drops. Voltage on the other had would stay relatively stable provided the battery was up to par. You can replace the pressure switch with an in-line switch but I would certainly look for other issues first. Such as do you really need 25 PSI? Is the switch adjustable?. I would borrow or buy a cheap ammeter (auto store) and make some measurements. 1) startup current with open fixture
2) startup current with closed fixture (against head pressure)
3) run current with open fixture, and
4) run current with closed fixture (against head pressure)

If these tests are inconclusive, then I'd try a different brand of pump. One from an RV dealer perhaps.
 
Top