agreed...rules of thumb get you in the ball park...sometimes it is spot on and you avoid the prop run around...
The OP hasn't responded with the needed answers to the stickies, so it's hard to help....but:
1 inch increase in pitch = 2-300 rpm drop
@max power
1 inch increase in diameter = 2-300 rpm drop @ max power
1 increase in number of blades (3 blade to 4 blade) = 2-300 rpm drop @ max
cupping a prop = 2-300 possible drop in rpm @ max power......
Mercury "command thrust" motors have bigger gear case diameters than a "standard" motor......so ( as I found out) some props will fit, but not work .....
these #'s aren't hard and fast...so don't beat me up....but it's researched results I came up with when propping my boat. A lot of this info came from iboats......