Would not go with SS with that water condition. I am a die hard SS guy but SS has it's limits. 4950 on a 5 liter is getting on up there isn't it? Going to suggest a Turning Point Hustler alum which is a high performance alum prop in 4 blades. Go to their www and read their advertising (
http://turningpointpropellers.com/_CONTENT/hustler-aluminum-boat-propellers.php). They cup a lot of their props and I don't think it would hurt you....see below.
Would look at their 4 blade alum. which do better at slower speeds in holding the boat at desired speed/attitude and improve water toy pulling than 3 blade. Hustler also has a lot of props ported which are holes in the barrel to improve hole shot. This may or may not help you playing with water toys. Holes let the engine unload and rev up faster in the hole and initially coming out, usually around 1k rpm higher till you get up to speed and it locks up....holes get blocked off by water pressure and rpm drop back to normal. If you are pulling water toys you may not get up to adequate speed to seal them off and you will be running high rpms and low speed which you don't want nor need. The 4 blade alone will do the thrusting in the hole and seems you have rpms to spare (plenty of power) to power a 4 outta da hole with de toys!
So, since they say their 4 blade does not suffer losses from 3 blades that other props do, go with a 4 blade of the same pitch, unported. If cupped, at WOT it acts like a higher pitched prop by 1" usually and that wouldn't hurt to pull your rpms down a little.....shouldn't your WOT max rpms be more like 4800? Should make up for the 4th blade drag and allow you to keep your top end as you have it.
So in summary 14.25 (or as close as they have) x 21 alum 4 blade cupped, no port holes. If it does what they say, that ought to fix you up.