well no i had a 150 efi on it and bought the 200 efi and rebuilt it is what the prop that was on it when i bought it now i never had teh problem with my prop on the 150 but it has a 24 pitch high five on it but would only turn 5200 rpms and ! yes i have checked the tach with another one and its right ! its on a 1994 ranger 374 i bought new in 94 so its a one owner boat ! maybe i should take the 24 off the 150 and put it on there ! i did not over rev it because when it got to 6000 i backed off back to the 5800 ! this prop was on it when i bought it probably why it bowed up i am thinking ! why i kept it for so many years it still looks like this potp taken last year lol !
do i have this right? you had a 24p on a 150, and now a 21p on a 200?
uhh... 24p high 5 on a 150 WILL make less rpm than a 21p high 5 on a 200...
if you want to stay with the high 5, first try put the 24p that you have on the 200.
HOWEVER, the high 5 is the wrong prop IMHO for a bass boat. You probably want a 3 or 4 blade, not a 5. For 3 blade you want a tempest plus or a fury. tempest for more speed, fury for better holeshot. for a 4 blade you will want a rev4 or a bravo 1.