1975 Johnson 50 hp, runs but wont idle

Archangl7

Recruit
Thread starter
Joined
Sep 19, 2016
Messages
4
I have recently ended up with a 1975 50hp johnson, and i have checked compression, its 90 psi on both cylinders, I have spark on both, rebuilt both carbs other than the jets cause i didnt have the tools but did soak in chem dip. I adjusted timing as it was advanced a lot, but may have been due to the power pack and coils being replaced. I used a small canister with new gas, and it will run, but wont idle or hold a straight rpm, i have to rev it to keep it running. From what i can see there is no reason for it to not idle at this point. It was running before i cleaned the carbs, or changed the timing, but the ramp down on rpm's is much smoother since i adjusted the timing. I have the manual for this specific model, and if i dont get an answer that i have not tried yet, the the mechanic will have to fix it and i will be super bummed. I already dropped it off at the mechanic, but i dont want to pay the high price, so help please!
 

oldboat1

Fleet Admiral
Joined
Apr 3, 2002
Messages
9,612
In practice, though, changing a power pack usually doesn't change timing. Anyway, another option is to let the shop set it up for you this time, and get what info you can for future reference. It's a good practice to work on one thing at a time when troubleshooting; it's also a good idea to make friends with a shop -- may want to just bite the bullet this time since they have the motor. Let them recheck the compression as well.
 

Bosunsmate

Admiral
Joined
Apr 7, 2012
Messages
6,135
CHeck your plugs, are they the same colour? Do a drop test? See if one cylinder is not firing.
I bought one of these once, it went through many people trying to trouble shoot it including chief mechanics, it ended up being that the bottom crankshaft seal had worn, since ive fixed that ive had no problems since
 

Archangl7

Recruit
Thread starter
Joined
Sep 19, 2016
Messages
4
A crankshaft seal caused it to stall? I dont know much about motors, but that sounds odd. I only inspected one plug when i pulled it, even though i took out both. I think i realized something was not right when i did the low speed jet adjustment. Is there a second screw that sits on top of the needle? there is a brass one with a sort of cup on the bottom, and if you look down in there, there is a second screw head it looks like. The brass one, that is visible on the exterior of the carb is not in the diagrams. Thats why i assumed it was the needle, but when i look it over again, i dont think i adjusted the needle, but rather a sort of set screw on top of it.

In the pic, you can see the screw heads of the brass pieces. When you remove them, the other end does not resemble the needle in the manual at all.
 

Attachments

  • carb.jpg
    carb.jpg
    98.9 KB · Views: 2
Last edited:

Bosunsmate

Admiral
Joined
Apr 7, 2012
Messages
6,135
A crankshaft seal caused it to stall? I dont know much about motors, but that sounds odd.ll.

Yes, on a four stroke it might be odd but with a two stroke if the crankcase seal is gone you dont get the draw of fuel and air through the crankcase in the lower chamber.
Same happens in the top chamber if the top crankcase seal goes.
You can test for crudely for this by holding a dollar bill in front of both carbs and see if they suck evenly.
No idea about those screws, its ages since i did mine. I think of mine most were fixed orifices so i just blew carb cleaner down each one and checked it came out somewhere strongly. I found a blocked channel in a carb once by noticing that it only dribbled back out another hole, that fixed my backfiring low power issue
 

Archangl7

Recruit
Thread starter
Joined
Sep 19, 2016
Messages
4
Interesting, would there be any other indications of the crank seal being bad? As far as that goes, thats not an easy fix either huh?
 

Bosunsmate

Admiral
Joined
Apr 7, 2012
Messages
6,135
Interesting, would there be any other indications of the crank seal being bad? As far as that goes, thats not an easy fix either huh?
Most times its done by a process of elimination of everything else. Spraying engine start under the flywheel can help diagnose the problem as the gas gets sucked into the engine through the worn upper crankcase seal and thus the engine runs different when thats done if the seal is bad.
You can pressure test the crankcase through the fuel pulse line, ive never done that so cant make any comment on that.

One way ive done it before is cleaning up the plugs, then grounding the HT wires on the engine elsewhere and turning the engine over briefly.
Both plugs should be wet with fuel when you pull them out after that to inspect them, if one of them isnt then that indicates that fuel is not getting sucked into the engine which means a bad carb or a bad upper or lower seal depending on which plug it is that is dry
 

Bosunsmate

Admiral
Joined
Apr 7, 2012
Messages
6,135
Oh upper seals an easy fix on a lot of engines, i cant remember on that one. Id have to look up a diagram of it and no point doing that unless youve run the diagnosis to check thats what it is.
The lower one is a pain as you have to lift off the powerhead, if its a freshwater motor its not too bad but if its a salty the bolts that hold the powerhead to the midsection can be seized and thats a no fun job at all. The seals and powerhead to base plate gaskets are all cheap, like $30 for all and once done you should get many many years of use from them
 

racerone

Honorary Supreme Mariner
Joined
Dec 28, 2013
Messages
40,028
My compression tester would read about 140 / 150 psi on one of those motors.
 

Archangl7

Recruit
Thread starter
Joined
Sep 19, 2016
Messages
4
So, update on the engine. I had a mechanic work on it, and it was kinda crappy because i figured out what was wrong after he disassembled it already. The jets had been screwed in so hard they were stuck and separated from the screw, and they were lodged inside. He removed them and put the new ones in, but now it does not seem to have the oompf it should. It is on a 16 ft aluminum v hull, and i am only getting 20 mph wot, and about 3500 rpm. The prop is a little dinged and doesn't have a cavitation ring, but shouldn't it perform better than that?
 

racerone

Honorary Supreme Mariner
Joined
Dec 28, 2013
Messages
40,028
The high speed jet is screwed in tight from day one at the factory.-----They are not adjustable !!----------Low speed jet may not be adjustable either.
 

flyingscott

Fleet Admiral
Joined
Apr 8, 2014
Messages
8,348
You need to double check that compression like racer said. If that is your true compression which is far to low you are in for a rebuild.
 
Top