Ok some background. Im not a outboard mech at all. However I build and tune motors all of the time. Last motor I built, dynoed and tuned peaked at 800hp. So I understand power drops, fuels systems etc. When you say that the Johnson has 80-95hp at the prop is that peak HP? What does the entire run look like in TQ and HP is it a flat run holding consistent TQ and HP? Or does it spike and then drop off? How about the Mariner is that peak HP and what does the run look like through the rpm range? If they both peak at the same HP but the Johnson due to larger displacement holds TQ and HP at higher or even levels through the entire rpm range and the Mariner is lower through the RPM range then to me it would be worth using the Johnson. Idont care about Peak HP, I care more about what power it holds through the entire rpm range. As far as the fuel pump being 110gph, that is just a volume measurement. Ill look and see if it has some sort of pressure regulator and see what pressure it holds. Im just looking for the best bang for the buck here. Its a fish and ski boat. So if this Johnson holds HP and TQ through the range it will pull people much better with less power loss.