1957 Fd-11 question.....

dyooperya

Cadet
Thread starter
Joined
Feb 16, 2012
Messages
13
Hello O wise ones......
Hope some of you can decipher this....sorry if it's a little vague.

So I recently purchased a twin to my grandfathers FD-11. I wanted to have two or more of them, because I just do,. I also picked up a parts FD-11 at an auction for 10 bucks a few years back. Prolly just needs coils/points/impeller and carb cleaned. But I bought it to sit in the boat house in case I ever needed parts.

Over the winter I've rebuilt both of them, as in the basics. Carbs, impellers, coils-points-condenser, fuel lines ... and all around spit and polish. My grandfathers engin went well and runs like a top as it always has. The new purchase FD-11 has been fighting me. And I need to say that this engin was torn down to pistons by a father and 14 year old son as a project. The son wants to be an engineer and the father thought this would be a good project, I liked that. However, I well knew what I may be in for, when I saw that they had cut the gaskets themselves through out the power head, with a paper thin type gasket material. I'll add that I liked this kid, and told him if he ever wanted the engin back, to give me a call and it's his for the same price. .....they needed to sell it to fund their second project, a dirt bike rebuild....but I could tell he was pretty attached to this old 57.
On this engin, I decided to pull the power head for a better look see....

I'll back up a bit.....bought it with tank for $250. It looked like it may be a low hour engin due to gear case fin paint was intact. And although the whole unit had been cleaned, the original paint from top to bottom was in very very good shape. The kid stated they had only tank run the engin for a sort time, and his Dad nodded his head in agreement.

I didn't have much time to really look hard at the engin as I was on my way home to Cinci after working on our cabin for 3 months deep in the north woods of the UP of Michigan. Also picked up a 57 Starcraft Ski Champ in Petoskey earlier in the day for a hundred bucks. Bottom looked like it had never been on the beach.

So when I pulled the head and the lower unit, I noticed a fairly good layer of black older looking oil/tar covering its insides. I was able to easily wipe off what I could reach. I don't have a compression checker, but when pulling the engin through, it sure seems to have good compression. And ran well today on the lake, after tuning, with equally good power and top end as Ol'reliable, maybe better.

So anywho, I bought new gaskets for the power head, inspected the head as best as I could, torqued all nuts and screws and reassembled the FD-11. Set the needles to factory, and it fired right up in the tank. I ran it for maybe 3-5 mins and shut it down. After I took it out of the tank, I noticed black oil leaking out of the area of the two rear power head screws. It was about an inch wide, and ran down to the impeller discharge. Note, the power head screws and nuts were torqued and then re-torqued an hour later. I used permatex #2 on the power head gaskets, lightly.

Today, I Lake tested it. And after fine tuning the carb, it ran perfectly. Low speed idle was really sweet, and top end, smooth as silk. Brought it back to the ramp after a few hours and there was the black oil stream again......

I've run my grandfathers FD-11 at our cabin in the U.P. of MICHIGAN since I was 5 and each year since for a total of 58 years. Never noticed a black oily stream coming down the aft of the lower unit. Maybe it has from time to time, but I'm a fairly detail oriented guy and never saw one. And it didn't leak black oil two days ago when I Lake tested it.

So, O wise ones, and much more knowledgeable than me.....what's up with the black oil ...??.....my novice guess.....this engin was run with a heavy fuel/oil mix....like 16-1 for years. Maybe the remnants of straight 30 weight from years gone bye. And it will clean itself out after I run 24-1 for a while. ???? But I just want to be sure it's not something more sinister....

Thanks fellas,
Dave
 

dyooperya

Cadet
Thread starter
Joined
Feb 16, 2012
Messages
13
Let's try this again without the back story, sorry.
I bought a 1957 FD-11 that's been apart down to pistons in hand, by a father and son for a project.
Engine looks like it may be low hour.
I rebuilt the carb, new impeller, points, condenser, coils, plugs and wires. All seemed to be recently replaced by the father and son, except coils and wires, coils were still producing a spark but seemed weak. But since the motor is going to a very remote cabin, I wanted to make sure all were correct parts and new.

What I did notice after I got it home, was that they cut all gaskets for the power head, and base of the head, from a paper thin gasket material....except the actual head gasket.

I've had it on a locale lake 3 times now for a total of around 10 hours. It seems to run fine from idle to full power.

I did pull the power head to get a closer look at the engine and their work. I checked and torqued all nuts and screws.
I replaced the paper thin power head base gaskets with oem.

I've seen no leaks while running it with the hood off, nor after, on inspection.......except a stream of black oil looking stuff that seems to leak out of the General area of the two rear most screws that hold the power head on. And runs down the back of the engine 6-7 inches. And seems to only start leaking, after I've shut it down. By the time I get home, it's run down the 6-7 inches. I've looked closely around the base of the power head with the hood off. Yes, it could be getting washed off while it's in the water and I just can't see it. I can't see any other leaks of black oil.
I'm now assuming I screwed up somehow when I replaced the power head base gaskets.....but I was pretty careful and used a light amount of permatex #2.

I'm trying to decide if I should take this engine up to the cabin, Or just use it here in Ohio and find another one to take up. Yes, I should of probably just replaced all the gaskets with new ones, for some reason I just didn't and now I'm low on time before I'm leaving to head north.
Any thoughts on why it's leaking the black oil looking stuff...??

Thanks

Dave.
 
Last edited:

oldboat1

Fleet Admiral
Joined
Apr 3, 2002
Messages
9,612
There are a couple of good shops in Curtis, if by chance that's where you are headed. I've taken a number of motors along up there, some that weren't quite ready for prime time, with the idea that I could get help if I really needed it. I think I would try out the '57 up in the UP, with a back up motor or two in hand. Worst case, it comes back to Ohio for some more work.

I think there should be a couple of gaskets up there, sandwiching a baffle. Not sure what a little leakage would mean, though, other than making a slow mess. Think it might function OK.
 

dyooperya

Cadet
Thread starter
Joined
Feb 16, 2012
Messages
13
There are a couple of good shops in Curtis, if by chance that's where you are headed. I've taken a number of motors along up there, some that weren't quite ready for prime time, with the idea that I could get help if I really needed it. I think I would try out the '57 up in the UP, with a back up motor or two in hand. Worst case, it comes back to Ohio for some more work.

I think there should be a couple of gaskets up there, sandwiching a baffle. Not sure what a little leakage would mean, though, other than making a slow mess. Think it might function OK.

Thanks for the reply oldboat1. Well I go past Curtis on the way, but I go about 175 miles further lol. We're just in a pretty remote area up there. There was a guy about 30 miles from us who worked on outboards, but he's been gone for 10-20 years. I'll order two more gaskets to take up with me. I'll have the needed tools with me, but just not a place to work on it.....I guess the kitchen will do lol.
I must of screwed up at least one of the two gaskets that sandwich the plate. Sure thought I was being careful. Ah well.....
I guess it's just some exhaust leaking around those rear screws.

And it does seem to run fine, but it's gonna bug me till I get it fixed. The plan was to have the 57's ready for 60 more years of service. I need to learn to be more flexible like the wife says I guess. I'll run it up there and see how it does, maybe bring it back down and replace all the power head gaskets over the winter.

Thanks again,

Dave
 

oldboat1

Fleet Admiral
Joined
Apr 3, 2002
Messages
9,612
Ha. deep into yooper country -- Hemingway, Harrison, Lightfoot. Maybe a pasty and some smoked whitefish around metropolitan Naubinway....

All good -- good trip to you!
 

dyooperya

Cadet
Thread starter
Joined
Feb 16, 2012
Messages
13
Ha. deep into yooper country -- Hemingway, Harrison, Lightfoot. Maybe a pasty and some smoked whitefish around metropolitan Naubinway....

All good -- good trip to you!

Hahah well we are about 60 miles NW of Marquette And the pastys and smoked whitefish will be on the menu for sure.

And I'd add Charles Van Riper to your list of Authors. Cully Gage is his pen name.
He was the son of a local Doc in a little mining town south of us. Charles became the father of speech pathology and wrote story's of his young days growing up in this small town.....good reading while at camp, or when you are wishing you could be there, don't cha know by golly.....lol
 
Top