120 Looper very occasional hesitation

ktime70

Cadet
Thread starter
Joined
Jan 2, 2012
Messages
16
My 1989 V4 looper has been having a consistent "miss" or hesitation.

Has plenty of power to get out of the hole, Idles fine.

Basically, at WOT, the motor hiccups once every minute and a half, and then runs perfectly again. the hiccup feels like a miss on one cylinder for momentarily. enough to send a shunt through the boat, but not enough to loose any speed.

at less than WOT, the problem occurs still, but less frequently than 1:30min.

I have checked fuel, ran it from a different tank (boat has 2 tanks), with a new hose/primer ball. Checked and replaced all fuel connections that were remotely suspect of sucking air. I have replaced all fuel filters since the problem emerged, with no improvement

fuel is fresh, premix (VRO disconnected) 50:1 evinrude xd50. Fuel is from a reliable source with no ethanol.

Tonight i am checking the fuel pump for output flow and pressure. IF the fuel pump tests ok, where should i look after this as the pump is my last idea

All engine/powerpack connections are clean and tight.

Adam
 
Joined
Jan 17, 2011
Messages
73
Re: 120 Looper very occasional hesitation

When is the last time you put a set of spark plugs in it? If you have done that check your spark.
 

ktime70

Cadet
Thread starter
Joined
Jan 2, 2012
Messages
16
Re: 120 Looper very occasional hesitation

plugs are6 month old
 

SparkieBoat

Captain
Joined
Aug 17, 2009
Messages
3,643
Re: 120 Looper very occasional hesitation

sounds like maybe water in your fuel..some isopropyl alcohol %90 in the tank will evaporate it. or change/clean water separator.
 

ktime70

Cadet
Thread starter
Joined
Jan 2, 2012
Messages
16
Re: 120 Looper very occasional hesitation

Fuel pump pumps strong with no bubbles/froth. will throw some isoprop in the tanks on the weekend and give it a run. Water makes sense as the trip before we got the problem, I finally got around to hooking the second tank back up. now i drained it, but due to the baffling may not have got all the old fuel out.
 

ctriverhouse

Cadet
Joined
Apr 12, 2011
Messages
17
Re: 120 Looper very occasional hesitation

Fuel pump pumps strong with no bubbles/froth. will throw some isoprop in the tanks on the weekend and give it a run. Water makes sense as the trip before we got the problem, I finally got around to hooking the second tank back up. now i drained it, but due to the baffling may not have got all the old fuel out.

My 1990 120 was doing the same thing. I replaced the power pack and it was fixed. When running WOT it would cut out for a mili second. Sounded like a skip.
 

ktime70

Cadet
Thread starter
Joined
Jan 2, 2012
Messages
16
Re: 120 Looper very occasional hesitation

My 1990 120 was doing the same thing. I replaced the power pack and it was fixed. When running WOT it would cut out for a mili second. Sounded like a skip.

Sounds like the same problem. Thought the miss/skip seemed too instant and short lived to be fuel.

Will still try drying the fuel, However, going to lean towards power pack.

What damage will it do to run the engine with this skip if it is the power pack?
 

SparkieBoat

Captain
Joined
Aug 17, 2009
Messages
3,643
Re: 120 Looper very occasional hesitation

none...but it would be a difficult problem to diagnose. because if it is missing that quickly and intermittent.
 

ktime70

Cadet
Thread starter
Joined
Jan 2, 2012
Messages
16
Re: 120 Looper very occasional hesitation

Well the boat has since recieved new plugs, leads, fuel pump, reg/rectifier, and powerpack, new filters, lines, and new fuel.

Problem is still there...

Tacho still doesn't work despite new reg/rect (might be seperate issue? tach never worked even when it was running fine)
 

daselbee

Commander
Joined
Jan 20, 2009
Messages
2,765
Re: 120 Looper very occasional hesitation

Ummm...well there is a slight possibility of a different type of problem.

It sort of sounds like the clutch dog in your lower unit may be jumping a cog every now and then.
That problem occurs at higher RPM, but it generally will make a noticeable clunk, like maybe you hit something.

Is it possible that you are having a "milder" version of that problem?
 

SparkieBoat

Captain
Joined
Aug 17, 2009
Messages
3,643
Re: 120 Looper very occasional hesitation

you really should test your parts before replacing them....
 

ktime70

Cadet
Thread starter
Joined
Jan 2, 2012
Messages
16
Re: 120 Looper very occasional hesitation

Ummm...well there is a slight possibility of a different type of problem.

It sort of sounds like the clutch dog in your lower unit may be jumping a cog every now and then.
That problem occurs at higher RPM, but it generally will make a noticeable clunk, like maybe you hit something.

Is it possible that you are having a "milder" version of that problem?

would the engine rev up when it does that? as i'm picturing it working similar to a slipping clutch in a car. prop-engine connection temporarily disengaging, thus the motor free spooling...

Sparkie, i was convinced elsewhere that an intermittent fault like this wouldn't show up in static testing of the components, that they would test normal, except for the instance where the fault was occuring. and as nothing else showed up, i started throwing parts at it based on the assumption my "bad" parts might be testing "good".

I have retained all the parts i swapped just so i've got spares, but i agree, i much prefer fault finding than shotgunning parts at a problem. but my mechanical experience stops where the water starts unfortunately.

Cannot find any other fuse than the small red one that fuses the control box under the cowl.
 

daselbee

Commander
Joined
Jan 20, 2009
Messages
2,765
Re: 120 Looper very occasional hesitation

would the engine rev up when it does that? as i'm picturing it working similar to a slipping clutch in a car. prop-engine connection temporarily disengaging, thus the motor free spooling...


No it doesn't rev up at all. Just a kinda jerk like your skeg went thru a sand bottom. As I said, most times it "clunks" pretty bad.
Yours might be milder.
 

SparkieBoat

Captain
Joined
Aug 17, 2009
Messages
3,643
Re: 120 Looper very occasional hesitation

if the skip is constant, like every 90 secs, then you could test it and the skip should show., maybe a coil shorting out, a run at night would help to be able to see a short. but if you do DVA test it may show a weak component..so for $25 I would get a dva adapter and do the test..the best advice I know to give. the other post about the clutch dog slipping is a possible problem also. after you have tested all electronics and timing and confirmed compression and are sure its not fuel..that pretty much leaves the gear case.
maybe you could post a video on u tube.
 

ktime70

Cadet
Thread starter
Joined
Jan 2, 2012
Messages
16
Re: 120 Looper very occasional hesitation

Ummm...well there is a slight possibility of a different type of problem.

It sort of sounds like the clutch dog in your lower unit may be jumping a cog every now and then.
That problem occurs at higher RPM, but it generally will make a noticeable clunk, like maybe you hit something.

Is it possible that you are having a "milder" version of that problem?

This is it, despite the mechanic i took it to saying it couldn't be. Problem now sorted.
 

daselbee

Commander
Joined
Jan 20, 2009
Messages
2,765
Re: 120 Looper very occasional hesitation

ktime....

Now that you know what it was, did it feel like you touched bottom, or hit something, like I described?
It is hard to try to explain how a clutch dog feels when it jumps a cog.

Did you look at the parts, replace the lower unit...how did it get fixed?

If you looked at the clutch dog, and the gear faces that it engages, you would immediately see that it won't "free-wheel" like
a car clutch that is slipping.

One other thing.....don't linger through the shifting process. Push that control lever into forward or reverse quick, without letting it make any grinding noise. It should just clunk into gear smoothly. This will help prevent any premature wear on the new clutch dog.

Good to see you got it. Sure took a long time tho.....
 

ktime70

Cadet
Thread starter
Joined
Jan 2, 2012
Messages
16
Re: 120 Looper very occasional hesitation

Yeah, I can see it now i know the problem. It felt Uncannily like a stuttering manual transmissioned car in gear. Also, I hadn't really ever dragged the leg on the bottom before, so didn't know what that felt like LOL (most my running is in deep lakes and offshore, not much shallow water stuff)

Ended up with a whole lower unit, as the one that was on it had significant corrosion (like almost through the housing in places), due to being stored on a docked boat in salt water at some point in it's life.

Yeah, it did take a while, Admittedly 2 months of that it was sitting at a mechanic who gave it back no closer to the solution, Plus it was winter here in Australia, so no real motivation.
 

daselbee

Commander
Joined
Jan 20, 2009
Messages
2,765
Re: 120 Looper very occasional hesitation

Also, I hadn't really ever dragged the leg on the bottom before, so didn't know what that felt like LOL (most my running is in deep lakes and offshore, not much shallow water stuff)

LOL....unfortunately for me, I have named my boat "Bottomfinder".
 
Top