JimS123
Fleet Admiral
- Joined
- Jul 27, 2007
- Messages
- 8,178
I had the same Seafarer and ran a 25 Yamaha 2-stroke on her, at 125 pounds. It was a very comfortable ride and the boat was certainly not overloaded.There's a few reservoirs here and there in NJ and PA but for the most part if you can run a gas motor, it doesn't matter what type.
One big issue is that many older boats have a tough time handling the added weight of a four stroke. For years I ran a 1970 14ft Starcraft Seafarer, rated to 25hp, if I hung a 25hp modern four stroke on it I'd likely have freeboard issues at the 15" transom.
The same on my current 1978 Mirrocraft 17 ft Lake Fisherman, its rated to 50hp, but I doubt it could handle the weight of a 50hp four stroke with the driver's position being at the very rear of the boat, and the battery and fuel tank also being aft midship in that boat. It goes well with an older 35hp OMC, and I've been knocking around building it a fresh 50hp two stroke, but its so well balanced out now, I don't think I'd gain much with the 50hp over the 35hp, other than loss of freeboard and a few MPH.
I've got a small 12ft jon boat, 30" wide that's rated to 10hp, I have no doubt that a 95 lb four stroke would all but sink it when I got in the boat. It barely sits above the water line with just me and an electric trolling motor.
A current Mercury 25 4-stroke would be 32# heavier, which I personally don't think would be an issue.
IMHO, the weight difference factors in a lot more for larger engines. Small tiller models are only slightly heavier.