All yalls transactions could be legit, but it could have been stolength 25 or 30 years ago and then sold or something where he aquire it in a legit sale, an then gave it to you.
No one is saying you stole it just that it seems like it could have been in the past. The right thing to do would be to contact the police and maybe a dealer and have them run the number. Chances are there is nothing if this is old. Before digital records were good. And it could be from a small area a state over...and would your police know?? No way, and probably no way to look it up?