Lower unit shock

for sale

Recruit
Thread starter
Joined
Jul 14, 2017
Messages
3
New to this forum and OB motors. Looking at a used boat with a 1991 48 hp SPL Johnson motor. I was advised by a Johnson/Evinrude mechanic to stay away from Johnson/Evinrude 40/50/60 hp motors 1988 thru 1992. He said the lower units are weak,have design issues,etc,etc. He also stated that the lower units are hard to find and come at a premium cost if you do find one. Any thoughts or truths to this? And no he was not trying to sell me one of his motors. Whatcha think folks......
 

jbuote

Lieutenant Junior Grade
Joined
Aug 17, 2016
Messages
1,001
I'm so new to outboards, I have NO info on if there are issues with those years as you were told, or not....
​I looked it up though....
​I have a 1971 50hp, and the Gearcase & Bearing assembly (Lower unit, NO internal parts) is about 3 times as expensive for the 91 as it is for my 71.. (Roughly 1700 US for the 91, and 500US for the 71..)
​
​That said, the parts inside aren't that much different price wise as far as I can tell.. (Those that are comparable anyway...)
​I know it's a BIG difference in years, but I would have thought my older 71 would be more expensive..
​So, as long as the outer casing of the LU doesn't break/crack/leak etc... Maintenance shouldn't be TOO bad...
​That is, providing there AREN'T any known failure rates for the 91 LU..

​Unfortunately, I'd wonder and question the choice now knowing about the drastic price difference...
Not sure I'd get one, and may even watch closer what is on my next boat I plan on getting in the next year or two..

​I guess what I'm saying is, Thanks for bringing this up! Something I think I want to keep an eye on now too...

​I have no real advice to offer other than my thoughts above, but will be watching this to see what the folks here that are really in the know have to say about it..

​For what it's worth...
 

flyingscott

Fleet Admiral
Joined
Apr 8, 2014
Messages
8,348
New to this forum and OB motors. Looking at a used boat with a 1991 48 hp SPL Johnson motor. I was advised by a Johnson/Evinrude mechanic to stay away from Johnson/Evinrude 40/50/60 hp motors 1988 thru 1992. He said the lower units are weak,have design issues,etc,etc. He also stated that the lower units are hard to find and come at a premium cost if you do find one. Any thoughts or truths to this? And no he was not trying to sell me one of his motors. Whatcha think folks......

He is right about the lowers being weak on the 2 cylinder models. I would say it is more years than that. There is a 3 cylinder 60 hp in those years that is a good motor and good lower.
 

racerone

Honorary Supreme Mariner
Joined
Dec 28, 2013
Messages
40,028
Correct ---there are issues with those lower units on all 2 cylinder 40 / 50 / 60 hp .-----The 89 to 92 were rare as far as finding good used ones.-----Price of parts ?----Many older parts are now being " cleared " out of the parts warehouse.----You can not judge / make decisions based on those prices.
 

for sale

Recruit
Thread starter
Joined
Jul 14, 2017
Messages
3
Thank you,jbuote for your response and research. Still shopping around.
 

for sale

Recruit
Thread starter
Joined
Jul 14, 2017
Messages
3
Well I think it's obvious that I don't know how to reply to each individual post,so thank you jbuote,flyingscott,faztbullet and racerone. I hope y'all get to see this post. I do know how to click on "LIKE"....LOL.
 

jbuote

Lieutenant Junior Grade
Joined
Aug 17, 2016
Messages
1,001
You're welcome for the thoughts! lol....

​I'll add though, that based on what others have posted here, I would not make a decision based solely on part price..
​As racerone pointed out, sometimes things are being cleared out, and market can change, so pricing NOW doesn't necessarily indicate pricing in the future when parts are needed. Could be more or less expensive when actually needed..... It's simply a consideration at the time of shopping..

​Seeing what the others posted, I'd be more concerned with what kind of issues the LU's have. It's been noted that other years are also believed to have some issue in the 40/50/60 hp range... I'd want to find out more about that too..

​I know my 50 is a Hydro-Electric shift. I see lots of posts advising some to stay away from it mainly due to price and availability of parts, but it's what I have, and so far the shifting isn't the problem with it.. LOL

​Anyway, I wouldn't "Not get" the engine based on prices per se', but rather on opinions on reliability and ease of maintenance (Do it yourself, or local shops willing to work on it etc...) for what you're looking for.

​Hope that clears up my thoughts a little..
 

racerone

Honorary Supreme Mariner
Joined
Dec 28, 2013
Messages
40,028
Those Hydro - Electric units on the 2 cylinder 50 hp are MUCH more robust than the newer / smaller diameter casing replacements starting in 76 I believe.
 
Top