1972 Johnson 50HP electric shift problem

DanNeedsHelpWithBoat

Cadet
Thread starter
Joined
Mar 29, 2016
Messages
20
Is it a clean break or a jagged one ??

It was a clean break.
Today I actually went out to a boat junkyard about 15 miles from my house and I was able to pull a complete lower unit off a 1973 and do a straight swap out. I also replaced the impeller while I had the lower unit off. Everything seems to be working fine other than it tends to want to die in reverse at low throttle which used to not be a problem....any idea what that could be?
 

racerone

Honorary Supreme Mariner
Joined
Dec 28, 2013
Messages
40,028
A 73 unit is NOT a straight swap out.---Totally different shift set-up.----Model numbers help here.
 

boobie

Supreme Mariner
Joined
Nov 5, 2009
Messages
20,826
Have you given the unit a good lake test with the new lower unit on it yet ?? A clean break on a drive shaft indicates a high impact break, not a housing bent or something out of line.
 

jbuote

Lieutenant Junior Grade
Joined
Aug 17, 2016
Messages
1,001
Yeah...
​Still REAL new to these, but as I understand it, a 73 had hydro-mechanical shift.. NO solenoids, so no wire to hook up..
​I think 72 was the last year for Hydro-Electric.. That has solenoids for the shifting..
NO power to either blue or green shift wire was forward gear.
​Power to just Green, is Neutral, and power to BOTH Green and Blue is reverse..

​Not sure the year, but there was also "Electric Shift" (might be on the Envinrude badge ,not sure)
That was power to one wire was forward, power to the other was reverse.. But NEVER apply power to both..

While the shift switch in the remote looked very similar, it was different..

I have to agree... What lower unit did you really get? what year? etc.... A 73 lower unit would not be a straight swap as I understand it...

Not trying to step on any toes or anything.. .Just hoping to help somewhat.. :)

​For whatever that's worth...
 

jimmbo

Supreme Mariner
Joined
May 24, 2004
Messages
14,699
The true Electric shift came out in 1962, on the Top of the line 40hp and V4, that system was last used on the V4s in 1968 and 1970 on the 40hp

The Hydro-electric was introduced in 1968 on the 3 cylinder 55hp and then on the V4s in 1969, Last year for it was 1972

Shift switches are NOT interchangeable between the two designs

In 1973 the Hydro-mechanical was introduced on all engines 50hp and above. It was discontinued on the 2 and 3 cylinder loopers in 1975, and the last year for it in the V4s and V6s was 1977

The straight mechanical was introduced on the 76 2 and 3 cylinder loopers and the V4s and V6s in 78.

There is no way a 73 gearcase can be used on a 71 or 72 engine. No linkages and no way to retro fit
 
Last edited:

oldboat1

Fleet Admiral
Joined
Apr 3, 2002
Messages
9,612
Whatcha got there, Dan? Maybe didn't actually have a '72, or maybe picked up a l.u. from a '71 donor motor? Sounds like you have something that partially works....
 

DanNeedsHelpWithBoat

Cadet
Thread starter
Joined
Mar 29, 2016
Messages
20
A 73 unit is NOT a straight swap out.---Totally different shift set-up.----Model numbers help here.

I checked and saw that the shafts were the same part #. The guy at the junkyard said they were a carryover year. the lower unit housing matched up perfectly as well....I haven't put it in the water but the engine fired up and seems to be shifting fine F and R in my driveway.

How are they different?
 

DanNeedsHelpWithBoat

Cadet
Thread starter
Joined
Mar 29, 2016
Messages
20
The true Electric shift came out in 1962, on the Top of the line 40hp and V4, that system was last used on the V4s in 1968 and 1970 on the 40hp

The Hydro-electric was introduced in 1968 on the 3 cylinder 55hp and then on the V4s in 1969, Last year for it was 1972

Shift switches are NOT interchangeable between the two designs

In 1973 the Hydro-mechanical was introduced on all engines 50hp and above. It was discontinued on the 2 and 3 cylinder loopers in 1975, and the last year for it in the V4s and V6s was 1977

The straight mechanical was introduced on the 76 2 and 3 cylinder loopers and the V4s and V6s in 78.

There is no way a 73 gearcase can be used on a 71 or 72 engine. No linkages and no way to retro fit


I guess i should clarify that is it Hydro Electric shift and not Electric shift.
I actually just re-checked and mine is 71' not at 72....brain fart. the model i took it off was #50ESL73R. it had the same two green and blue wires going down the exhaust shaft down to the lower unit. both lower units look identical.
 

racerone

Honorary Supreme Mariner
Joined
Dec 28, 2013
Messages
40,028
Only a 71 or 72 model lower unit will fit ----Period.-----73 models do not have wires . had a shift rod !
 

jbuote

Lieutenant Junior Grade
Joined
Aug 17, 2016
Messages
1,001
Hmm... That donor motor model number says it's a 73... But, as pointed out, 73 didn't have shift wires...
​Betcha somebody put a 71 or 72 engine on a 73 transom mount? My 71 has the model/serial plate on that transom mounting bracket..
​If it got swapped out, maybe that's where the disconnect on the years is? :noidea:
 

DanNeedsHelpWithBoat

Cadet
Thread starter
Joined
Mar 29, 2016
Messages
20
Hmm... That donor motor model number says it's a 73... But, as pointed out, 73 didn't have shift wires...
​Betcha somebody put a 71 or 72 engine on a 73 transom mount? My 71 has the model/serial plate on that transom mounting bracket..
​If it got swapped out, maybe that's where the disconnect on the years is? :noidea:

this has to be the case...the lower units were identical, has the shift wires, the top of the motors looked exactly the same too. The only difference was they kind of jerry rigged a tiller steering and control to it so i imagine that there was some other swapping out that occurred
 

oldboat1

Fleet Admiral
Joined
Apr 3, 2002
Messages
9,612
That sand around the water pump suggests to me you might have found a sand bar -- gonna guess that's where the shaft might have sheared.

Used to drive along the Susquehanna going up from Maryland to New York, or the other way. Always curious about the river runners in between all the rocks. Think sandbars are a little more subtle, but probably as hazardous to lower units -- and sandy water a killer for impellers. A couple of years ago, I got too close to one of the gravel bars here in the lake and pretty much destroyed my prop and rudder, so guess you pick your poison.
 
Top