Yamaha or Mercury 25 HP

ajg2

Recruit
Joined
Jan 1, 2002
Messages
5
What,s your opinion guys? Also 2 or three cylinder 2 stroke only? Need to keep it light. Thank you
 

PaulP

Seaman Apprentice
Joined
Jun 16, 2001
Messages
35
Re: Yamaha or Mercury 25 HP

Have been looking myself,Yamaha makes both a 25 hp 2 cyl 106lb and a 3 cly 130lb.<br />Merc 25 is a 2 cly 112 lb. I would go yammie if price is no object. stay away from Suzuki,see other posts on that subject. Happy Hunting.
 

suzukidave

Petty Officer 1st Class
Joined
Jul 1, 2000
Messages
387
Re: Yamaha or Mercury 25 HP

Hey, wait a minute PaulP, alegator wasn't even thinking about a Suzuki and so I think your gratuituous shot at Suzukis is a bit cheap. Those recent posts deal with Suzuki 4 strokes, and he's looking for two strokes in which case the Suzukis are tried and true. Four complaints about admitted unbelievably slow responses on repairs on a new technology does not in my mind completely trash a manufacturer that has made good motors for 25 years. Do you stay away from all Evinrudes & Johnsons because of the Fichts? Before two weeks ago you'd be hard pressed to find anything but positive comments about Suzukis on this site, including (maybe even especially) the 4 strokes. Nobody on this site knows why the sudden problem with Suzuki 4 stroke repairs but at least 4 possible explanations exist: (1) they have a manufacturing back order problem with 4 stroke parts because somebody screwed up or because the 4 strokes sold better than expected, (2) they have deliberately cut back on U.S. inventory because of financial (cash flow) problems caused by the recent economic downturn (inventory is first to go when a company is tight for cash), (3) they have multiple design defects with the 4 strokes (the problems reported on this site are not all the same) causing a parts shortage; (4) Suzuki USA staff have suddenly turned into idiots who don't care what happens to their business reputation and intend to run a good brand into the ground with horrible service (in which case Japan will fire them soon enough). <br /><br />I make the suggested explanations in order of what I suspect is their likelihood. Since I have heard that their 4 strokes have sold like gangbusters and Suzuki has traditionally been small potatoes in the outboard market, I strongly suspect explanation #1 over 2, 3 or 4. I think we should give the company more than two weeks grace before we trash it completely. I wouldn't buy a new 4 stroke until I knew the answer but I think the 2 strokes are fair game provided you can find a good dealer (there's no question you want a local established dealer before you buy Suzuki)<br /><br />As a disclaimer, in spite of my login title, I have nothing to do with Suzuki. Apart from my 89 DT55, the only Suzuki products I've ever owned are a couple of dirt bikes twenty years ago (which were great). I just like my outboard and want to protect it's resale value! :D <br /><br />By the way Alegator, I own a 55 2 cylinder and I would go two cylinder unless you want to be able to troll. You have less weight and one less of everything to replace adjust and worry about. The 3 will run better at low revs.
 

dmessy

Chief Petty Officer
Joined
Jul 8, 2001
Messages
505
Re: Yamaha or Mercury 25 HP

I got a 2001 Mercury 25 hp, tiller, electric,short shaft,<10hrs. for a great price. Email dmessy@ev1.net for details.<br />I can highly recommend Mercurys, very reliable, great dealer support,built in USA. They've got thier stuff together (especially small outboards) after many years of R&D.<br />Yamaha? Great ,big motors.Have friend who won't own another one(60hp)due to inheirant problems. I believe $ and dealer support in your area to be the deciding factors. :D
 

ajg2

Recruit
Joined
Jan 1, 2002
Messages
5
Re: Yamaha or Mercury 25 HP

Thanks guys for the information. I am leaning toward the 2 cylinder Merk or Yamaha as I have a dealer near by that handels both. Suzuke no longer offers a two stroker this small. I agree that the Suzuke two strokers were great motors. Forgive the spelling please. Merc does have the best price by $300.<br />Also I am not planning on trolling and may occassionally trawl with a 16 foot net. In years past though, Merk had a problem with salt water but I think they have overcome the corrosion problem. What have you all heard? Thanks again - Alegator
 

Trent

Captain
Joined
Nov 17, 2001
Messages
3,333
Re: Yamaha or Mercury 25 HP

Spend the extra 300.00 get the Yammie
 

ajg2

Recruit
Joined
Jan 1, 2002
Messages
5
Re: Yamaha or Mercury 25 HP

Thanks Captin. I think you're right.
 

lilwily

Cadet
Joined
Sep 25, 2001
Messages
24
Re: Yamaha or Mercury 25 HP

Last year I bought a Mariner 25hp that I<br />love....I have always been an OMC man myself.<br />Mariner and Merc are the same except the <br />color and sticker on the side. The motor is<br />a 1997 and was on display...never started in<br />the box. I picked it up for 600!!!! What<br />a steel....The motor has run and run...The<br />price made my decision for me...now I would<br />buy another anyday. It is the regular 25m<br />short shaft. The manager where I got it told<br />me the price and my jaw dropped!<br /><br />I have it on a 14' Mirrorcraft v-hull....<br /><br />Wily
 

ajg2

Recruit
Joined
Jan 1, 2002
Messages
5
Re: Yamaha or Mercury 25 HP

Thanks for the input Willy. Glad to hear some good about the American motors also.I am powering a 15 foor 48" Alweld that weighs about 400#s. I think a 25 HP will move it about 25 MPH with 2 men. Thanks again -<br />Alegator
 
Top