Picking reels for others is a very hard thing to do. For starters, nobody knows your ability with bait caster reels and therefore it becomes hard to state which would be the better for you. If your familiar with using bait caster reels, then pick the one YOU like the best and get use to how it functions. If your not familiar with bait caster reels, then maybe buy a used cheap one and learn before buying something with more or different options. Bait caster reels work a little different from open face and reels like Zebco 33's. But once learned they are very nice to use. I actually researched and looked at all three models you specified and honestly, you can't really go wrong with either one of them... All three have basically the same 7:1 retrieve ratios, ball bearings are near equal as well with Sheet Reese Victory having the most with 7. All are about the same weight and that leads to less fatigue, and all have magnetic drag capabilities as well. So I see it as a mere coin toss. And all three have lots of thumbs up for likes too. I guess pick the one that looks the best to YOU! GO fish it! JMHO!