What's your filet knife of choice?

muddog

Cadet
Joined
May 29, 2002
Messages
13
After butchering some filets with an old knife that no longer will hold an edge I realize it's time for a new one. Anyone have one they love? OR hate?<br /><br />Thanks
 

JB

Honorary Moderator Emeritus
Joined
Mar 25, 2001
Messages
45,907
Re: What's your filet knife of choice?

Howdy MudDog, <br /><br />Rapala. Touch it up with a steel before each use. After about 30 years it still holds an edge very well.<br /><br />"Will no longer hold an edge" sounds suspiciously like you need to rehab the edge from scratch or you want a new knife.<br /><br />Whichever, Rapalas are very good knives at reasonable prices. :)
 

Fishbusters

Ensign
Joined
Apr 20, 2002
Messages
921
Re: What's your filet knife of choice?

Wish i could tell you but my uncle bought it and gave it to me for my birthday. Unlike most it has a rubber handle and stays sharp. I have never seen any more like it except the one he has. I know he mentioned one time that it cost something like $30 so take good care of it. For all I know it could be a comercial model or something.
 

ebbtide176

Commander
Joined
Jan 22, 2002
Messages
2,289
Re: What's your filet knife of choice?

some cheap knives will hold an edge, and some don't. my pop has an old rapala that must be @ 20yrs old. its so worn down its half as wide as it used to be, and works even better due to this. to me, a good filet knife needs to be narrow,thin & flexible. but i have a plastic handle kmart cheapo, and it works fine for me. the whole 'trick' is sharpening. this cheapo holds an edge well. but i never could sharpen a knife like pop could. its kinda like an inherit trait my country relatives had but i didn't get it. <br />** until i got a knife sharpening 'system'** hehe<br />-just a thought-<br />rapala would be my choice for a good filet knife. but if you're interested in putting an edge on a blade that is unbelievable, get a kit. i got mine several yrs ago for less, but you can get one for @$31 at http://www.theoutdoorcenter.com and i saw some in stock in the local bassproshops. it even works on huge or tiny knives, altho i take the blade out of my 'mouse' pocketknife to sharpen it.<br /> i got the lansky basic kit(plus get a stand):<br />
2407104.jpg
 

JRJ

Commander
Joined
Sep 11, 2001
Messages
2,992
Re: What's your filet knife of choice?

I like Rapalas and long Russells for salmon. My wife uses them in the kitchen all the time so I've got a drawer full of them. When one dulls, its nice to just grab another.
 

muddog

Cadet
Joined
May 29, 2002
Messages
13
Re: What's your filet knife of choice?

ebbtide176 – we must be related. I never got the sharpening gene either. <br /><br />Thanks for the feedback guys it’s looking like I might try a Rapala (and get a new sharpener/steel) Keep the feedback comin
 

dingbat

Supreme Mariner
Joined
Nov 20, 2001
Messages
16,082
Re: What's your filet knife of choice?

The Rapala is a good knife but I've snapped two of them in the last five years. Kershaw and Dexter Russell is all that I use now.
 
Joined
Apr 23, 2002
Messages
61
Re: What's your filet knife of choice?

I ususally don't like to argue but I have been down this road before and I have found the answer.<br />Hands down, without a doubt, the best filet knife is an electric filet knife. American Angler makes one with a lot of power and a 10 inch blade - cuts through the rib cage like butter.<br />I fileted a 20 pound striper this weekend and the same job would have taken twice as long with a traditional filet knife. Not to mention - the filet is much neater when it's all done and skinning the filet couldn't be easier.<br />Electric Fisherman is another brand but they both run about 30 bucks. Serrated edge double blade - never needs sharpening (replaceable blades too, you can get the 12 volt for the boat or plug in for the house. Cleans up in a jiffy - just wiggle it in the water while pushing the button.<br />I'll never go back to traditional filet knives again. ;)
 

DTB

Cadet
Joined
May 12, 2002
Messages
21
Re: What's your filet knife of choice?

One of my last salmon trips I left my fishing knife behind so I pulled out my 8" boning knife from my chef bag it's a Wustholf Dreidzac Trident series stainless steel hand forged holds a great edge a little pricy but I got one for the tackle box when I got back. They run about $90.00 Canadian.
 

derwood

Chief Petty Officer
Joined
Mar 11, 2002
Messages
499
Re: What's your filet knife of choice?

I like a fillet knife to be long, thin, not to wide(i like the used ones better, they are trained) and sharp as ****.<br /><br />As far as the sharpening gene goes. That takes a little practice, but it's not hard. You have to get a feel for it. When you have the touch down you can feel the knife get sharp like its a part of you.<br /><br />I will use a jewelers file to work on a new edge at first. I hate factory edges, they suck. Its probably from all those years of sharpening new machettes. They could'nt put an edge on a blade if they tried....and they don't try very hard.<br /><br />If you take it down just a little with the file, and then start to work on it with the stones, its a little faster and easier to control the edge. I must tell you that it's easier for ME. Not every one can get the hang of using the file on a blade.<br /><br />I can take a blade, and just using a file, I can make it scarey sharp. Not many folks can do it without messing it up. Thats a lot of years of complaining partycheifs under my belt. They always say "sharpen my blade, we've got a mile of line to cut today." Then they forget they said it and go to use it and cut through the tree and into their shin. I've seen it happen a dozen times. <br /><br />When it's sharp you can take the knife and hold it with 2 fingers at the but of the handle and just the weight of the blade will take it through a piece of paper like it was melted butter......oh yeaaaaaa.<br /><br />I agree with JB. Rapalas are gooood knifes. He also hit it on the head with the "start from scratch." thing. That thing will sharpen till the day it's so thin it bends from it's own weight.<br /><br />derwood.
 

crab bait

Captain
Joined
Feb 5, 2002
Messages
3,831
Re: What's your filet knife of choice?

i have to give you fillet knife sharpeners credit... i can flat-out sharpen a knife.. it's got-to-be-one of my best skills.... but i be darned if i can sharpen a long flimsy ,flexin' thin piece of blade steel to save my butt..
 

paintermn

Seaman
Joined
Sep 17, 2001
Messages
65
Re: What's your filet knife of choice?

Great replies!<br /><br />We went from which knife to how to get them sharp which is the real answer anyway. ANY decent knife is good if it is sharp.<br /><br />Sharp knives are kind of my "thing" and I go though this whole long process when I sharpen a knife which involves about five different stones. Course diamond to very smooth natural stones. the last being a very rare smooth Arkansas stone from my father (looks like marble).<br /><br />To buy a good knife: Besides the obvious outdoor suppliers, do what I do as an ex restaurant manager: Go to a restaurant supply store , or online, and shop for their specials. I have two Russell's that I got for five bucks this way.
 
Top