Why does new boaters likes to ask how to obtain best prop advice if they haven't tested their current one. If you plan using that combo lightly loaded or with few boating mates, that light boat with a 40 HP should fly direct to Mars.
Standar factory delivered props on light to medium applications gives excellent hole shot and good top speed. Just throttle accordingly your boating requirements for more or less speed.
Some issue about Tohatsu OB's, likes being vertical trimmed and spot on transom height seated. Works best with water flow skimming right under small upper water defector plate (yellow line) as opposed to middle or near anticav plate for best prop thrust and overall combo water performance including tight close turns at any water cond.
In order for a Tiny Tach to read correct rpm, must be set to 180? usually comes factory set to 360? at that settting will read double rpm. That engine wot revs at 5200-5800 rpm. What you need to do is place a mate up front at bow, go for a wot spin on flat glassy non wind water cond , check if having out or over transom water splashes and max WOT rpm achieved. If inside middle to max (5500-5800 rpm) stay with that prop, if over revving slightly throttle less. You can install that tach at front of cowl, next to tiller to monitor engine revs at all times.
Post current wot rpm and GPS speed.
Happy Boating