Every year for the last 12 years we've been going to Long Beach Island NJ for summer vacation. The fishing was great! Stripers, Fluke, Rays, Skate, Blues, etc. The cost of a rental on LBI went up so much that for the same money we can go to the island of St John. I'm the only one in the family that doesn't want to go. I love the NJ fishing. What kind of fishing do you do in those Caribbean Islands. Can I fish in the surf? Are there striper and blues sized fish or do you have to go deep sea fishing? If I catch Nemo, my kids will kill me! All I want to do is sit on the beach and fish. I don't even know if thats legal!