Water in my oil - Arg (read the sticky)

soaked

Cadet
Joined
Jul 5, 2008
Messages
24
1979 Merc 260 - closed cooling system - SE106 outdrive

End o last year, found water in oil after many hours run time... found small amount the year before, but dismissed as fluke.

Boat ran fine for a few months (May - July), oil was normal (no foam) but I kep losing coolant. Strange. I assumed into the bilge, but was wrong. After a few long days fishing in early July, I found the bilge covered in oil and the oil pan over full (half of it water).

Assumed it was head / gasket problem, but puzzled by smooth running. the started thinking it was passive intrusion, after I shut it down... But the exhaust mani's are new. Went with the heads... When I called for a new gasket kit, the folks at Go2 Marine suggested I check the exhaust mani's for leaks, before I tear into heads. Easy enough.

Found Don S. sticky on acetone test - super handy. But, no leaks in mani's.

Read recent sticky from Don S. on "Water in my Oil - Arggg" Darn strait, ARRGG! After reading, I was convinced I had a cracked block. Decided to pressure test. With exhaust manifolds off, I rerouted the heat exchanger tubes directly into the Intake manifold, closing the system. Removed thermostat and pressure tested to 15 psi. Pressure held steady. I even pulled the oil drain plug hoping to see water drip out. Nothing - no sights no sounds.

Now what?

I am interested in replacing intake, distributor and carb with newer stuff (edlebrock combo and thunderbolt IV). Would give a chance to visually check for cracks at valves - but pressure test should have indicated trouble, right?

Should I replace head gaskets and test the heads while they are off? (assuming I can find someone local who can test them)

Any suggestions? I was almost happier with the notion of a craked block...

As always, thanks for your thought and opinions..

J.
 

ENSIGN

Lieutenant Junior Grade
Joined
Jun 21, 2009
Messages
1,179
Re: Water in my oil - Arg (read the sticky)

With the engine running,slowley remove the cap from the heat exchanger fill it to the top and check for bubbles,this would point to a head gasket problem or a crack that may only leak when it gets warm.If there's a engine oil cooler installed remove and pressure test this.Hope this helps,Ted
 

Don S

Honorary Moderator Emeritus
Joined
Aug 31, 2004
Messages
62,321
Re: Water in my oil - Arg (read the sticky)

I guess the big question is, are you getting water in your oil or antifreeze? With a closed cooling system, if you actually have water and the closed cooling system hold pressure. Then water probably got in through the carb.the oil fill cap, or something like that. Did the boat fill up with rain water? As I understand it, it does rain a bit in SE Alaska.
 

soaked

Cadet
Joined
Jul 5, 2008
Messages
24
Re: Water in my oil - Arg (read the sticky)

Don, good question, I will check this evening or today at lunch - still have the pans contents in the vac tank.
 

soaked

Cadet
Joined
Jul 5, 2008
Messages
24
Re: Water in my oil - Arg (read the sticky)

OK, it's coolant in my oil. Any thoughts? Like I mentioned, no pressure leaks in the cooling system or block. But I tested with water in the system and block, assuming I would see water leaving the oil pan after a while...

Should I start replacing head and intake gaskets.

The block is very rusty, and I'd like to pull it apart to thoroughly clean it up and re-paint, along with a clean-up if tghe bilge area (and replace parts)... just hate the thought of doing all that, putting it back together and end up with the same problem...
 
Top