Don't understand the "if you epoxy them you are SOL". It can be removed like anything else if need be.
I have not removed epoxy myself but the guy that paints my log does. From what I can tell he used some sort of paint removing grinding wheel. I have used such a wheel to remove paint on other items and it doesn't remove any metal. What it is a a soft black woven wheel that gets chucked in an air grinder or drill.
Epoxy is different than bottom paint....it's a 2 part setup, you add a hardener chemical to it to activate it. When it dries it basically coating your pontoon in an ultra hard plastic. I even called the manufacturer of the epoxy I used on my old toons and they confirmed that it's not coming off. The stuff i used was called Coat-it, it's designed to use on boat bottoms that frequently hit rocks.....tough stuff...but i would not recommend it for toons.
Hmmm, well i guess whatever works. I just know from my experience that i will never do that againHere in Florida it is common practice to use epoxy as a primer and bottom paint over. I believe the epoxy is used as a barrier for the paint. It is recommended for pontoons by the dealers here on a regular basis if the boat is left in the salt water.