Re: Trophy 2302 boat prop
The reason there are so many choices is first of all price some folks buy for price some for performance,some prefer ss props for their somewhat better parformance and toughness.Some folks want just plain speed in a srtraight line others want to run at greatly reduced throttle to the exclusion of all else. There are props that provide stern lift/quick hole shot,some provide bow lift, some resist venting better than others, there are 2,3,4 and 5 blade props then you can consider any number of manufacturers.
A person that wants to go fast would use a comepletely different prop than a person that does a lot of water sports.
A person that runs with a boat load of people basic cruising would need a different prop than a husband and wife that do the exact same thing.
A person could run with any old prop and get by but performance and econmy would likely be poor
and over time could ruin the motor.
I think you can see the likely hood of finding the exact same boat used the exact same way is unlikely.
If you give us the info required in "read this first" we can help you select a prop.
Guessing at the gear ratio it appears your setup isn't working.