James in NC
I'll try again but, when I put the new starter on I checked all cables(cleaned the ends) and changed the battery connector at the battery. I don't take the cable off the solenoid, but when I told it off Saturday I don't see any corrosion, thus my thinking it may be the solenoid.It is very likely that your starter never needed replacement, James. Three out of five starters that are replaced aren't bad. Remove all big cables from the battery to the engine and the one from the solenoid to the starter. Clean both ends thoroughly, check for weak spots and corrosion, then replace. If there is any weakness in a cable, replace it.
Let us know what you find.