My starter would not engage and would only spin. I have checked it all from Battery to Starter. I replaced the solenoid. I took the starter off and used a dc power source and the cranking motor turned just as it is supposed to and the pinion gear raised. When I try to start it now all I get is this clicked noise and the starter does not spin. Any ideas why. I don't want to buy a new starter and then find that is not the problem. Shouldn't it work in the outboard if it works when I take it off. Also the neutral switch works fine it won't turn over when in gear and out it clicks when I try to start it. Could it be a wiring issue in the wiring to the starter but the power wires look like they are in great shape to the solenoid but the small "s" and "i" wires to the solenoid had some insulation melted off so I taped them up.