One of the spark plugs on my 56 johnson 15 is bad. The insulator does not appear to be damaged, the plug does not look worn out, but I have no idea how old the plugs are. I know that it is bad because I can swap cylinders and isolate that it is the problem. The plugs are c j6. I cleaned the carbon off the gap areas and now it only will almost fire, still no good. <br /><br />My question is, can a plug look good but still be bad? I have always been able to clean and correct a fouled plug before. Just wondering. Also, why such a heavy tarnish of carbon? I guess that is a symptom of something wrong?