So many choices!

Frostz28

Seaman Apprentice
Joined
Apr 9, 2021
Messages
32
Hello all, been lurking around for while and finally decided to join up. From what I've seen this is a great place for information with a lot of good people! which shouldn't be a surprise given the friendly nature of the boating world. That being said I hope you will all forgive me for asking what I am sure has been asked a MILLION times over by new members. The question is what boat should I buy.... Don't worry I have more information. First of all I am not new to boating... not really anyway. I have been on boats and around them my entire life. My family has always had a boat and a couple of years ago I bought my first boat myself. 96 crownline 18' bow rider, I love that boat dearly! Problem is life has changed, and I now find myself wanting/needing things that the current boat just can't do. I started looking around and honestly was a bit overwhelmed with the number of boats and brands and options out there! As I said I am not "new" to boating, however I am new to looking for boats. In the past my father always did the boat shopping and he was always just looking for value. He never bought a "cheap" boat but also never believed in paying for something he didn't NEED in a boat. Low hours, well maintained, enough power to pull skiers and tubers and reasonable price. That was his search criteria and it served us well. At the time it was just the 5 of us. My parents and the three sons. Now we are all grown, have kids of our own and our boating habits have changed drastically. the old crownline and rinker are still getting the job done but they're is room for improvement. ALL that being said I now have myself, my wife, and my son's boating priorities to take into account along with the yearly trip to the lake with the whole family. Now before I begin the list please understand that I am aware it is impossible to get a boat that would cover ALL things. Just looking for peoples input, opinions, suggestions etc. on something that might straddle the middle a bit. SO..... For starters I'm looking to be in the 20'-24' range. I personally love sports cars, motorcycles, and such so I enjoy a sporty boat with some power! I don't need to be the fastest boat on the water by any means but I do enjoy getting up and moving! If it was just me Id be looking for a Crownline LPX just love the way they look and sound. However, my son loves tubing, and LOVES long boat rides. He would sit in the front and ride for a week straight if he could. Him and the wife also LOVE pulling up to the beach and hanging out at the back of the boat. we spend time on the river during the summer but the boat's main use comes on our trips to the lake (2-3 times a year for 4-8 days at a time) The lake is large and can develop some decent chop from time to time. Its no place you want to get stuck in a boat that doesn't handle chop trying to beat a storm back to the dock! So basically in a perfect world I would like to find a boat that, can pull skiers and tubers, handles chop at least decently, has a good comfortable lay out for longer day trips, has a large swim deck off the back, a walk through transom would be awesome... .and on a selfish note I would love a boat that has enough power to make it fun to drive, and has a sporty kind of look to it.. maybe Captain's call exhaust.... oh and it HAS to be an open bow. My wife and son would kill me if they couldn't sit up in the bow. is that too much to ask!? lol Anyways, thanks for listening to the same old question once again. let me know what you guys think. Whats your favorite boat in that size range and why. Oh yeah as far as price...... I don't think I could ever pull the trigger on a brand new boat but for the right boat I could PROBABLY get the boss lady to go for 20-30k.... maybe... lol
 

lrdchaos

Petty Officer 1st Class
Joined
Feb 11, 2008
Messages
265
We recently picked up a Monterey 238ss with a 350mag engine and I think it fits most of your requirements. It’s 23ft overall, feels wide and we like the layout for long cruises, plus it can be pulled by my wife’s Tahoe. We chose a boat without a tower as well so that it would fit in smaller garages saving us money on storage every month. Our boat is a 2015 and we paid low 40s, but it’s in really good condition. If you're looking to spend 20-30 and want a boat that holds a group of people you’re going to have to look at the 2000-2005 boats most likely. And just a fair warning boats are going for a premium right now so go in knowing you’re going to pay a little more than you would have in the past. At the end of the day, I figured that we were going to keep the boat for 8-10 years so if I paid an extra 3-4K to have a boat now and enjoy the summer with the kids it was worth it to me.
 

Frostz28

Seaman Apprentice
Joined
Apr 9, 2021
Messages
32
We recently picked up a Monterey 238ss with a 350mag engine and I think it fits most of your requirements. It’s 23ft overall, feels wide and we like the layout for long cruises, plus it can be pulled by my wife’s Tahoe. We chose a boat without a tower as well so that it would fit in smaller garages saving us money on storage every month. Our boat is a 2015 and we paid low 40s, but it’s in really good condition. If you're looking to spend 20-30 and want a boat that holds a group of people you’re going to have to look at the 2000-2005 boats most likely. And just a fair warning boats are going for a premium right now so go in knowing you’re going to pay a little more than you would have in the past. At the end of the day, I figured that we were going to keep the boat for 8-10 years so if I paid an extra 3-4K to have a boat now and enjoy the summer with the kids it was worth it to me.
Funny that you say that. I just emailed about a 238. Really nice looking boat. I know boats are really high right now. Along with her skis, quads and anything else related to outdoor recreation. I'm hoping the higher market means a higher selling price for my boat to offset the higher price of the new boat.
 

Frostz28

Seaman Apprentice
Joined
Apr 9, 2021
Messages
32
Did you pick up the monterey as an upgrade from your previous boat? If so what did you have before? And what were the reasons you decided to upgrade?
 

lrdchaos

Petty Officer 1st Class
Joined
Feb 11, 2008
Messages
265
No, we had a Tahoe q7i for 11 years prior to this boat that we sold a couple years ago because we had two small kids and we’re not using it as much. When we started looking for another boat I knew I wanted a boat larger than 20ft, I really wanted to be in the 24ft range, but wanted a boat that was towable by my wife’s car and one that I could buy outright. This boat had 140 hours and other than a few dings, it’s a 5 year old boat, it was in really good condition. Plus it had the largest engine possible for that boat, which is really important.
 

Frostz28

Seaman Apprentice
Joined
Apr 9, 2021
Messages
32
Big engine is a plus!!! I don't need to do 70 or anything. Just enough to be fun to drive.... And of course beat my dad! lol how did you like the Tahoe?
 

lrdchaos

Petty Officer 1st Class
Joined
Feb 11, 2008
Messages
265
the Tahoe was fine, it had a 5.0mpi and bravo 1 out drive so it performed well. Fit and finish was what you would expect from a boat in the price range, but it kept us out on the lake for lots of weekends. It handled rough water like most 20ft boats do.
 
Top