Shark Meat Question

valleydawg

Seaman Apprentice
Joined
Nov 10, 2009
Messages
46
Ok since the only thing that I can catch now at Hilton Head seems to be sharks which ones are the best for eating. Is there generally a size to stick with? I have always heard the larger ones were full of mercury but I don?t know. Do you just make small steaks out of them? Skin? Thanks
 

robert graham

Admiral
Joined
Apr 16, 2009
Messages
6,908
Re: Shark Meat Question

Yep, we were at the S.C. coast week before last, and caught one shark after another. I've heard they were good to eat by just slicing into steaks but that old wives story about,"we don't eat sharks", came back up and we just threw them back. I don't see much reason why they wouldn't be good, especially since they're predators and not bottom feeders. If you eat one and don't die, let us know and maybe we'll try one!
 

HappierWet

Master Chief Petty Officer
Joined
Sep 11, 2008
Messages
839
Re: Shark Meat Question

I eat them on a fairly regular basis. The local supermarket sells shark steaks when I can't down to the salt. I'd prefer catching fresh to store bought. IME, The key to good taste is cleaning them quickly and keeping them cold.
We've cooked them as simply as wrapped in foil with butter and veggies, broiled like a steak, seasoned with bay seasoning, to some fairly complicated stuff my wife doctored up. mmmmm .....GOOD EATS:)
 

sasto

Captain
Joined
Jun 1, 2010
Messages
3,918
Re: Shark Meat Question

In my opinion....Mako shark is the best....and the only one I eat. I recommend releasing all sharks.
 

Beefer

Lieutenant Commander
Joined
Aug 4, 2008
Messages
1,737
Re: Shark Meat Question

If you eat one and don't die, let us know and maybe we'll try one!

:D:D:D

I agree with Sasto two-fold. Mako is yummy, but I prefer to release (not crazy about bringing them onboard (my secret wuss side)). Helps clean out the gene pool at the public beaches. :D
 

dingbat

Supreme Mariner
Joined
Nov 20, 2001
Messages
16,060
Re: Shark Meat Question

Make sure you know what species of shark your hacking into. There are currently 19 federally protected species of sharks.

Before going shark fishing, check the South Carolina Department of Natural Resources (SCDNR) regulations very carefully regarding shark fishing. There are very clear guidelines for each individual species of shark.
 

Fl_Richard

Lieutenant
Joined
Jan 21, 2005
Messages
1,428
Re: Shark Meat Question

Often you have to sever the head and bleed a shark immediately if you intend on eating it. I've been "told" they **** through their skins and if left on ice they will ruin the meat.

I know mythbusters look out.... It's all based on "heard that" rather than actual experience. I always cut the heads off and bleed, then ice them and they are always excellent! Kind of like swordfish steaks!

YUM!
 

sasto

Captain
Joined
Jun 1, 2010
Messages
3,918
Re: Shark Meat Question

Make sure you know what species of shark your hacking into. There are currently 19 federally protected species of sharks.

Before going shark fishing, check the South Carolina Department of Natural Resources (SCDNR) regulations very carefully regarding shark fishing. There are very clear guidelines for each individual species of shark.

If it's my shark, I am releasing her. No harm.
 

capt sam

Master Chief Petty Officer
Joined
Jan 14, 2009
Messages
878
Re: Shark Meat Question

Mote Marine did some research on sharks a couple of years ago and every shark they caught had high levels of mercury in their systems. I tend not to eat them anymore because it's a lot of work but now there's an additional reason.
 

rscuddvr

Recruit
Joined
Jul 30, 2010
Messages
1
Re: Shark Meat Question

Down here in St Augustine we get a lot of bonnetheads. They taste good, stick with the 3 to 4 ft range. I had one, didn't bleed it out, and the meat ended up tasting a little strong. I usually relese, but if I get another good one, I'll try the bleeding trick and see what happens....
 

JB

Honorary Moderator Emeritus
Joined
Mar 25, 2001
Messages
45,907
Re: Shark Meat Question

I have eaten Mako. Treated it exactly like swordfish and it tasted exactly like swordfish.

That was many years ago. Today I think I would release them all.
 

wallybme

Petty Officer 2nd Class
Joined
Dec 21, 2008
Messages
161
Re: Shark Meat Question

Great meat to eat, boneless and cartillageous. Most of my early life, 90% of my diet was eating seafood and shark was high on the list. We ate fish heads ..... made soup. I lived 100 yards from the great Atlantic. When I moved here in the mid seventies I was ashamed to share my experience of shark eating with anyone. Simply because it was not the norm. In the early nineties it began to emarge as a part of the diet and as a delicasy. I do not know the restriction on size to keep or release, but this I know, the smaller the better. When I had access to them, not over 30 inches before the off flavor emerges.

A good way to prepare shark (there are no bones in shark only cartillage):
remove the skin, then cut stakes about 1/2" to and 1" thick; dip in vinegar for about 3 to 5 minutes then remove. This will remove the smell and improve the taste. Next blend some onions, garlic, and other seasonnings of your choice along with salt with two eggs and 1/4 can of cream or milk. Cover the meat and leave to marinate for about 2 hours. Deep fry (until meat floats) or bake in batter @ 350 deg for 15 mins or until done. Do not over cook. Serve hot. Use a glass of red wine or beer.
I do not know about the levels of mercury.....I do not know if it is natural or a contaninant from the ocean and maybe the younger ones do not have the levels, but bear in mind the today I'll be cautious about any seafood based of so much environmental spills. Not only shark, and or salmon but any kind of seafood, even the farm raised.
Prepare eat and enjoy.
 

RicMic

Chief Petty Officer
Joined
May 14, 2010
Messages
431
Re: Shark Meat Question

I worked for a company that used mercury in their production, so we had mercury "awareness" meetings with various kinds of scientists, they ALL recommended NEVER eating any of the large long lived predatory fishes, especially sharks and swordfish! Don't forget that not all species of shark get big, many only get a couple feet long, but since they live a long time they can still have a high percentage of mercury(and other toxins).
 

adam7

Petty Officer 3rd Class
Joined
Jul 30, 2010
Messages
97
Re: Shark Meat Question

I have also heard the thing about the shark meat being soaked in urine. My brother in law caught a 4 foot one here in Beaufort (actually around Fripp) a few months back and I think he let it sit and soak or something for a while, then he made shark nuggets. Apparently they were pretty good.
 

RicMic

Chief Petty Officer
Joined
May 14, 2010
Messages
431
Re: Shark Meat Question

They aren't soaked in urine, when a shark or skate or ray(they are all related), gets stressed severly, such as getting caught, the waste products build up in the tissue faster than they can get rid of them, ammonia is part of the waste products. Lot of times if you fight one of those fish for a long time, they are already dead by the time you land them.
 

Woodnaut

Chief Petty Officer
Joined
Jul 4, 2007
Messages
634
Re: Shark Meat Question

A few years ago I saw a Black Tip in the local fish market. They're pretty common down here in the GoM. I've never eaten them though.
 

kemo111

Cadet
Joined
May 22, 2010
Messages
27
Re: Shark Meat Question

I have caught and eaten black tip sharks in the 40 pound range. My wife loves them cut into steaks and cook on the grill. They are a mild taste with the meat being a little tough much like pork loin. We gaff and slice deep to hit the artery by the gills then rope the tail and let it bleed out in the water then cut head off before bringing to the boat where we gut and put on ice.
 

scrat

Petty Officer 2nd Class
Joined
Sep 21, 2007
Messages
106
Re: Shark Meat Question

I fish for and catch sharks pretty regularly. In the hot summer months sometimes, it's about all you catch. I find the blacktips, Bonnethead, and Dog sharks pretty good. I gut them immediately then ice them down inside and out. Filet them out when back on shore, cut out any 'red' spots. Let them matinate in italian dressign for about an hour before grilling.... Yummy. In Ga, Blacktips need to be 3ft. Bonnethead and dog sharks around 2.5 feet. be carefull though dog sharks look alot like sand sharks and I think those have different rules.
 

RicMic

Chief Petty Officer
Joined
May 14, 2010
Messages
431
Re: Shark Meat Question

Do a search for mercury in fish or sharks. I don't think you will enjoy them after that.
 
Top