Re: Reverse/Neutral Outboard Problems on Mercury 125
First, a disclaimer: I'm throwing this out from experience on my '69 100 HP Merc, so it's possible that yours is different.<br /><br />It's normal for the prop to ratchet forward and lock the other way when the shifter is in forward mode. This is because the forward gear engagement uses a spring loaded pin against a "sawblade" shaped pawl. <br /><br />When the shifter is in neutral, the prop spins freely in either direction with no clicking noises at all. <br /><br />The reverse gear does not use the ratcheting sawblade type of engagement and instead has opposing rings of square pegs that move closer together and lock into each other. This means that the prop will not turn forward or backward unless you turn hard enough to make the powerhead turn too.<br /><br />Now, since you had a significant amount of forward momentum that was trying to keep the prop spinning one direction and tried to apply lots of horsepower in the opposite direction, the only place for all that power to go was against those opposing rings of square teeth. I would guess that the tips of those teeth got rounded out a little bit and the filings from that high-pressure contact is what you found in the oil. You may also have bent the shift shaft so that the cables need to be adjusted a few turns to compensate. On my motor, this is fairly easy to do by releasing a little lock lever (push in, 1/4 turn left, pull out 1 inch), spinning the mount block on the cable casing, and re-installing the mount block with the lock lever. If the shift shaft is bent to where it ALMOST engages forward gear when the shifter is in neutral, this would explain the clicking that you hear when you turn the prop. It would also explain why you can't move the lever far enough back to get reverse to engage.<br /><br />If adjusting the linkages doesn't get it back to the way it worked before, you might just have to bite the bullet and pay your local marine service shop a few Jacksons. There are very few backyard mechanics (myself included) who have the tools required to work on a lower unit. I'm as happy as can be to pull the powerhead apart and put new rings in, but I pay the local marine shop to do any work inside the lower unit.