Prop Test Results

matthewpa

Cadet
Joined
Sep 4, 2006
Messages
27
Just did a comparison between two props on my 18' Thompson Sea Lancer with Merc 140 I/O. What are your thoughts?

Old Prop is Merc SS Vengeance 21p
New Prop is Turning Point Aluminum Legacy/Hustler 19p

Conditions:
Temp: 59
Water temp: 57
Location: 5 miles northwest of Green Bay, WI on the Bay of Green Bay
Waves: 1-2ft for old prop test, 2-4ft for new prop


Acceleration Old New
0-10 1.3 .9
0-15 2.7 1.8
0-20 4.1 3.0
0-25 6.0 4.9
0-30 8.0 6.9



RPM & Speed Old New
1000 5.5 5.1
1500 7.0 6.4
2000 8.5 7.8
2500 13.5 12.4
3000 21 19
3500 26 25
4000 30.1 28.4
4500 35 34
WOT 37.7@4800 37.4@4800

Did not trim to much on the new prop due to the wave height. I think I might be able to get a little more out of it but may also send my RPM's above the recommended range of 4400-4800 for my engine.

The biggest issue I see with my 21p is with a full boat the engine only will turn 4400@ WOT and 35mph. I suspect that the 19p will be better with load.
 

Irv964

Petty Officer 1st Class
Joined
May 3, 2008
Messages
315
Re: Prop Test Results

Just did a comparison between two props on my 18' Thompson Sea Lancer with Merc 140 I/O. What are your thoughts?

Old Prop is Merc SS Vengeance 21p
New Prop is Turning Point Aluminum Legacy/Hustler 19p

Conditions:
Temp: 59
Water temp: 57
Location: 5 miles northwest of Green Bay, WI on the Bay of Green Bay
Waves: 1-2ft for old prop test, 2-4ft for new prop


Acceleration Old New
0-10 1.3 .9
0-15 2.7 1.8
0-20 4.1 3.0
0-25 6.0 4.9
0-30 8.0 6.9



RPM & Speed Old New
1000 5.5 5.1
1500 7.0 6.4
2000 8.5 7.8
2500 13.5 12.4
3000 21 19
3500 26 25
4000 30.1 28.4
4500 35 34
WOT 37.7@4800 37.4@4800

Did not trim to much on the new prop due to the wave height. I think I might be able to get a little more out of it but may also send my RPM's above the recommended range of 4400-4800 for my engine.

The biggest issue I see with my 21p is with a full boat the engine only will turn 4400@ WOT and 35mph. I suspect that the 19p will be better with load.

Great review, just the info I was looking for!........Irv
 

walleyehed

Admiral
Joined
Jun 29, 2003
Messages
6,767
Re: Prop Test Results

This is the perfect example of efficiency..
We have an entry level SS and what some call a high performance aluminum in 2" less pitch, yet slower at the same RPM. The cup is not placed in a location that can be used to "lift" the boat or the RPM would be higher....you did let it run at WOT, right?
It's a good test although results don't surprise me much.
Stay at it Matthewpa....this is the fun stough...:D
 
Top