It's a 1986 Ebbtide 19' cuddy with a 4.3 Cobra<br /><br />This afternoon while turning sharp at low speed I heard two loud "clunks" then at idle it was making some strange noises from the drive. We limped it back and put it on the trailer. When I got home I found metal in the oil so I took the cover off to find the upper gears shelled. Not enough beer to make the feeling go away, the worst part is the kids and wife love to go boating and with the Minnesota boating season rapidly winding down, we're out for the season. But I digress...<br /><br />I've got a few questions? What would make the unit "un-rebuildable"? <br /><br />Based on my snowmobile experience I know you can't have an upper part of an engine (or stern drive I assume) shell without metal getting into the lower. So, I assume the lower will need to be rebuilt too?<br /><br />I've been looking at T.C. Electronics and Marine and it looks like it will be worth fixing the boat rather than selling as is or junking. Any thoughts?<br /><br />What in the heck could have caused it? Here's the possible culprits I've thought of.<br /><br />I changed the lower unit oil a month ago, But I filled it according to the manual (pumped it up from the bottom, then after running it it was only down 1/2" so I topped it off)<br /><br />I hit some rocks a couple weeks ago. Banged up the prop enough to cause a vibration, so I put a different prop on and the vibration seemed to go away.<br /><br />Recently, if you turned hard to port or starboard it would vibrate a little. I assumed this was ujoints and was planning on changing them ASAP. Could the ujoints have cause this or do you suppose the vibration was this going all along?<br /><br />One last question. If I get the upper and lower rebuilt, and replace ujoints, gaskets, belows, etc, when putting it back on that should be it right? I just don't want to spend the money only to find out I've miscalulated and need another $1000 in parts.