Merc vs Volvo

cantaris

Petty Officer 2nd Class
Joined
Nov 16, 2008
Messages
159
Which is better? Mercruiser outdrive or Volvo penta 280?
I have a pre alpha merc in my 24 footer. It is the wrong gear ratio for my 165 L6. I have a chevy 350 from a donor boat that has VP 280 outdrive. I have to remove my setup any to replace my transom. Should I go ahead and change out to the VP or should I stick with merc and change to a newer model with correct gear ratio? Thanks
 

Bondo

Moderator
Staff member
Joined
Apr 17, 2002
Messages
70,994
Re: Merc vs Volvo

Ayuh,...

Is that a 280 With trim,..??

Personally,...
I find Merc.s to be Cheaper to work on,.. More of them around,.. More Parts sources, etc...

That said,...
I Wouldn't try mounting a Volvo dressed motor to a Merc drive Either.....
 

HT32BSX115

Supreme Mariner
Joined
Dec 8, 2005
Messages
10,083
Re: Merc vs Volvo

Personally,...
I find Merc.s to be Cheaper to work on,.. More of them around,.. More Parts sources, etc...
I have to say that I agree. When I was shopping around (briefly) for a new engine drive combo to replace my Wunderful OMC King Kobra, I considered both new Volvo Penta and Mercury stern drives.

That didn't last long. To get the same performance I had with the 460, I needed to spend about $24k

I then went looking for a VP or Merc used stern drive and found several Mercs and one or 2 used Volvos.

I like to do my own "stuff" I looked on ebay for example and discovered that at any time you do a search for parts, drives, engines, props, etc, .......I found 3 to 4 times MORE Mercruiser parts than VP. New or used. (Especially new old stock or last years models.... today, almost 2000 merc and about 600 VP....)

I looked for drives and stopped counting new and used Mercruisers but there was only about 10 older used Volvos on there.


Don't get me wrong. There's not a thing wrong with Volvo drives. If I had found a good deal on a Volvo before the Merc, I would have a Volvo hanging on the back of my boat and I wouldn't be looking back.

But now looking back I'm glad I found the merc first. I have no problems finding inexpensive new and used parts whenever I need them.

Incidentally, when I did a search on ebay in "Boat Parts & Accessories for "Volvo 280" I got 22 hits.

When I searched for Mercruiser Alpha, I got 368 hits and Bravo produced 2036 hits!!

Cheers,


Rick
bravoIII2.gif
 

chiefalen

Captain
Joined
May 18, 2008
Messages
3,598
Re: Merc vs Volvo

And thats it in a nutshell. XT3 hit the nail right on the head. I'm glad i didn't see you type in omc also.

Merc., just my 2 cents. For this instance anyway.
 
Top