Ok try 16:1......I know some of the guys above think you are joking, but there is some logic to what you are saying.
The 3hp is not a fully jeweled motor. (bushings). Being so, they need that extra oil to "seal". Motors like the TN and TD series 5hp actually idle BETTER on the 16:1 mixture. Todays oils are much better than the oil of old, inasmuch as it wont build carbon deposits like it used to. Run a quality oil, at 16:1, and let us know how it goes.
That being said, while the 3hp JWs are low compression motors, 65 is a touch low even for them. Did you check the cylinder bore for being out of spec? Perhaps the rings are worn, with too high an end gap? Did you dress the head, before installing new head gasket
The fact that the numbers are even between cylinders is a good thing.