I need some interview questions answered by a marine mechanic

Status
Not open for further replies.

Maniacal Fish

Recruit
Joined
Sep 14, 2009
Messages
3
Hi, IM a junior in high school and doing this paper on being a marine mechanic and i need some questions answered by one who is or is training to be or something like that.. it would be a GREAT help to me if someone could do this.. THANKS VERY MUCH IN ADVANCED!!!

Questions:
1. What made you decided to get into the marine business?



2. What Kind of risk?s did you have to take to get to the point your are now?



3. What kind of previous jobs did you have before your current job ?



4. What experience do you need for this job if any?



5. What is the range of work that is associated with your job?



6. What is the average starting income for a marine mechanic?



7. How many hours you work a week?



8. What kind of joy does your job give you?



9. What inspiration would you give anyone that is interested in becoming a marine mechanic?



10. Do you have any regrets for getting into the marine business?






11. What training is required to become a marine mechanic?
 

Silvertip

Supreme Mariner
Joined
Sep 22, 2003
Messages
28,771
Re: I need some interview questions answered by a marine mechanic

Question number 11 should be the first question on your list. You questions are all valid but many of them are "emotional" in nature and not directly related to the job. Questions regarding "mechanical and electrical" ability are essential as the new boats and engines are very complicated in that regard.
 

gstanton

Chief Petty Officer
Joined
Jul 3, 2003
Messages
451
Re: I need some interview questions answered by a marine mechanic

I would add that computer experience is necessary... NOT playing video games... but USING spreadsheets, databases and on-line resources to diagnose and repair a problem. In other words, computer as a tool and not just a toy.
 

pine island fred

Lieutenant Junior Grade
Joined
Dec 20, 2002
Messages
1,144
Re: I need some interview questions answered by a marine mechanic

Interesting subject, how did choise to do a paper on this subject? You must have somekind of interest. Not a marine mechanic but will try to give some insite from the way I see things as there are a lot in my area.
Q1- must people have somekind of interest in the business that leads them in that direction, sometimes it turns into a living, other time a serious hobby.
Q2- no more risk than any other carrier.
Q3- more than likely, somekind of mechanical job turning a wrench which evolves into working on boats.
Q4- Maby someone else can respond to this question.
Q5- more than likely, the whole boat and everything attached to it.
Q6- dont know what the pay is, lots of guys I see are just able to make a living wether they work for themselves or have jobs a marinas or boat repair shops. Ones who work for someone else tend to do a lot of moving around from shop to shop. Like guys at auto dealerships, always moving.
Q7- time varies, depends on the economy.
Q8- ???? some people like there jobs, others hate it. just me, I always got satisfaction by doing a good job and sending people on there flights in the morning on time in a safe product.
Q9- as for inspiration, just think it is something you are interested in and dont look forward to becoming a rich man doing it.
Q10- cant answer, maby someone in the business will jump in.
Q11- dont know if there are any schools for the trade. Must be as there are schools for motor cycle and diesel mechs.
Hope I have been of some help.
Now my take. 5 yrs. ago I would not recommend this to anyone but times are evolving and lots of people are retiring so there will be a demand. Would recommend an A&P school ( airframe & powerplant ). Time investment should be 14 to 16 months. Long haul but you do qualify to to take the test and get your FAA license. No one will immediately turn you loose on a plane but the fact that you went thru the school time shows that you are interested and responsible and you can take your trade anywhere. Dont have to be planes, you can work along side locomotive, truck, boat, big ships, construction equip. mechanics and get enough experience where you can do the job without someone looking over your shoulder. Another words, you are confident and people have confidence in you.
And NO, the military will not give you that kind of training regardless of what they tell you. Do the disciplin, be ready to learn from others and you will be OK. regards FRED
 

nitsuj

Chief Petty Officer
Joined
Jul 22, 2003
Messages
483
Re: I need some interview questions answered by a marine mechanic

I don't know how many marine mechanics we have here, so I don't know how many people will answer this. I'm going to answer them in case there isn't many marine techs here, that way you have more answers to choose from. I will point out that, strictly speaking, I am NOT a marine mechanic. I'm currently an unemployed motorcycle mechanic, but I am also a certified Yamaha PWC tech. Both boats and motorcycles are luxury items and the industries are similar, so some of my answers will over lap the marine industry.


Questions:
1. What made you decided to get into the marine business?

A love of it and a genuine mechanical ability.


2. What Kind of risk?s did you have to take to get to the point your are now?

No more than anyone else who has a job in an industry that fluctuates. Marine (and motorcycles) go through cycles. Some years, it seems like boat (and motorcycles) are very popular. Other years, they decrease in popularity. There's always the chance that you could end up laid off. Being good at what you do will usually prevent that though.


3. What kind of previous jobs did you have before your current job ?

Well, my current job is unemployed. Before that, I was a motorcycle tech, motorcycle salesman and sales manager and service manager in a motorcycle shop. Before that, I was a tool and die makes apprentice.


4. What experience do you need for this job if any?

Above all else, you need mechanical ability. I personally believe this can't be taught. I think some people are born with it. It's just how they're wired. My kid brother is an excellent guitar player. He taught him self and he's really good. I could have Eddie Van Halen give me lessons for 8 hours a day for years and I'd still not be good at it. I just wasn't wired that way. I also can't draw a picture. Some people are born being able to draw. You can't teach someone who can't draw, how to draw. Same with mechanical aptitude. You need knowledge to understand how things work. But with out a strong mechanical aptitude, the knowledge won't do much good. You can be taught to perform jobs, like oil changes and the like. But to be a professional, you need to be able to find problems that aren't listed in a manual. Theres a certain type of creative thinking involved.


5. What is the range of work that is associated with your job?

It's limitless. One day it's a complete engine rebuild. The next it could be simple oil changes. The day after that it may be bolting on accessories. Anything and everything needing done.


6. What is the average starting income for a marine mechanic?

That's a tough one. Lots of variables. Depends if you start your own shop or work for someone else. And your location. A boat mechanic in Pittsburgh isn't going to make the same as one in Miami. But the rule of thumb is, it's not much. The sad fact is, for as much skill as it requires, all types of technicians are vastly underpaid. I may be biased, but it's true.


7. How many hours you work a week?

In the busy season, sometimes 60. In the off season, 40 or less at times.


8. What kind of joy does your job give you?

Sometimes it gives tons. Other times, it can be a drag. Just depends. Sometimes you meet the greatest people on earth. Other times, you meet the biggest jerkoffs ever. Speaking for myself, one of my favorite things is taking something that doesn't run, finding the problem and fixing it. Then hitting the key and hearing the motor come to life. At the end of the day, you feel like you accomplished something. When I was in sales, I didn't get that. Sure, I could close a deal, but it never felt as final. Also, taking a machine that is neglected and running poorly and turning it in to a well running, and dependable machine is awesome. Must be how a doctor feels when he saves someones life.

9. What inspiration would you give anyone that is interested in becoming a marine mechanic?

First, be honest with yourself. Do you have the mechanical ability? No training will give it to you. Some of the best mechanics I know have no formal training. Some of the worst I know are people with no mechanical ability who got good training. Chances are, if you made it this far in life, you know whether you're mechanical or not. If your not, even though you may love boats, the job isn't for you. Go into sales or management or something else in the boat dealer. Also, make sure you're doing it for the right reasons. You have to have a genuine interest in being a mechanics and boats in general. If it's just a job, or a way to make money, you'll never have the pride in your work that it takes to be good. Pride in your work is the key. It's what separates a good mechanic from a great one. Every boat needs to be treated like it's your own. Like your name will be on it forever after you work on it.


10. Do you have any regrets for getting into the marine business?

None. Although sometimes I wish I went to college and got a job where I'd make more money, I know I'd never be truly happy doing anything else.


11. What training is required to become a marine mechanic?

This goes back to what I was saying before. The training is almost incidental. The schools give you motors that have been torn down 100 other times. They are sitting on a bench. The nuts and bolts are loose. You learn theory and how things work. But you don't learn the little things that you need to learn. Like stuck bolt removal. Or what to do when a bearing is stuck in a race. Personally, I think the best training is working in the shop environment under people who know their stuff. You will need specialized training in the particular brand you'll be working on, but the do it all schools they advertise on late night tv aren't worth it IMHO. Get a job in a shop. Work your way up from wash boy.
 

Silvertip

Supreme Mariner
Joined
Sep 22, 2003
Messages
28,771
Re: I need some interview questions answered by a marine mechanic

So the military doesn't offer quality A&P (airframe and powerplant) training huh? I beg to differ. I just happen to have a neice who has served aboard the carrier USS Ronald Regan since it was launched. She has been a helicopter mechanic/machinist all that time and has been recently reassigned to shore duty so she can attend Embry-Riddle Aeronautic University, specializing in power plant rebuilds. So much for no military training.
 

nitsuj

Chief Petty Officer
Joined
Jul 22, 2003
Messages
483
Re: I need some interview questions answered by a marine mechanic

The military provides training. But again, it comes down to the natural ability of the person being trained. No amount of training the world will make someone with no mechanical ability into a good tech. You're niece must have been born with a certain amount. I've seen people come out of the military who were trained as mechanics that we're terrible. Other who were great. Nothing against the men and women protecting this country, but just because it's military training doesn't mean it's magic. You still have to have a certain amount of raw talent.
 

Maniacal Fish

Recruit
Joined
Sep 14, 2009
Messages
3
Re: I need some interview questions answered by a marine mechanic

Wow!!! Thanks A Bunch Too Everyone!!!! You Dont Know How Much Yall Helped Me!!! Thank You Times A Billion!!!!! :d You Guys Rock!!
 

Ned L

Commander
Joined
Sep 17, 2008
Messages
2,268
Re: I need some interview questions answered by a marine mechanic

There are many different types of 'marine mechanics', everything from the guy at the local bait & tackle shop who tunes up small outboards to the guy that works aboard VLCC's & ULCC'S ( ie: supertankers). My brother was a marine mechanic for Mobil oil for almost 25 years (until a couple of years after they were bought out by Exxon). I?ll do what I can to answer your questions based on my brother.

1)What made you decided to get into the marine business? -- Our family grew up on the water & involved in boating from before we could crawl. He was always mechanically inclined - he grew up as the 'go to guy' for all his friends whenever they needed work done their cars & boat engines. As a teenager he became the 'go to guy' for all mechanical questions where we kept our boats. Just sort of a natural fit.

2. What Kind of risk?s did you have to take to get to the point your are now?
I don't think there were to many 'risks' involved for him ? slipping & falling off the deck in January snow & ice maybe.

3. What kind of previous jobs did you have before your current job ? He worked as an electro-mechanical technician at a local manufacturing company

4. What experience do you need for this job if any? He had an electronics degree from a technical school , as well as about 15 years of ?hands on experience? while growing up

5. What is the range of work that is associated with your job? As a marine mechanic for Mobil oil he was based at their marine repair facility on Staten Island NY. That was where the north east coast inland fleet was based. The inland fleet consisted of the tugs, barges, oilers, and small coastal tankers that supplied petroleum products up and down the east coast and Hudson River. His responsibilities were for the maintenance, repair, replacement, and upkeep of the diesel generators , pump engines, electrical systems, electronics, computer systems, navigation systems, and HVAC systems on the tugs & barges. This would involve anything from routine oil changes on engines at the terminal to being called in the middle of the night to drive to upstate NY in the middle of a snowstorm because a transfer pump engine on a barge wouldn?t start (or maybe the heating system wouldn?t work & a barge crew was getting cold). He would be called off for days at a time to go perform extended work if a tug or barge was being refitted at a shipyard somewhere (MD, VA, FLA) At times he would be called aboard at the last minute for a repair & the captain couldn?t wait so he ended up going along for the trip to the first stop (maybe Albany NY or Providence RI). There were times toward the end of the day at work when he was told he was needed somewhere ASAP, so he would leave then & there, driver half the night or whatever, buy new clothes when he got there & then spend a couple of days doing what was needed ? anything from maybe a complete engine teardown & rebuild on the spot to reworking an electrical & electronics system that was fried by a lightning hit.

6. What is the average starting income for a marine mechanic? Sorry, don?t know.


7. How many hours you work a week? 40 normally, up to 100+

8. What kind of joy does your job give you? It provided him with a career of varied responsibilities & types of work ? no two days were alike.

9. What inspiration would you give anyone that is interested in becoming a marine mechanic? If you love the water and being around it, are mechanically inclined, and enjoy a varied work environment it can be great.

10. Do you have any regrets for getting into the marine business? When working in the commercial side of the industry it can be hard on family life as it is often not always a 9-5 kind of business

11. What training is required to become a marine mechanic? I would recommend electrical & electronics training as well as maybe technical school automotive training (engines are the same & a lot of auto bodywork is based on similar types of principles).

A couple of things to keep in mind are that when working in the marine industry (marine mechanic) on pleasure boats your livelihood is relying on other peoples recreation, so when the economy has a downturn you are the first to not get paid. On the commercial side of things in the marine industry, opportunities have shrinking over the past 30 years (commercial fishing is down, the US Merchant Marine fleet has been shrinking for decades, government budges are tight & spending on things like ferries, DEP & EPA boats will probably be down).

Almost forgot, I went to college for Commercial Fisheries & Marine Technologies, so some of the comments are based on my own experience in the marine industries.

I hope this helps a bit.
 

Silvertip

Supreme Mariner
Joined
Sep 22, 2003
Messages
28,771
Re: I need some interview questions answered by a marine mechanic

Anyone, and I repeat anyone, with "apptitude" can learn to do most anything. Our forefathers learned by doing because there were no text books or institutions of higher learning to teach them the things that we now take with a grain of salt. Learning is an evolution of events. Some folks have more "apptitude" than others so they become better doctors, lawyers, teachers, and yes mechanics. A doctor, lawyer, or mechanic worth their salt will tell you if they think they can't help you and will recommend seeing a specialist. To make a blanket statement that the military does not offer good training is simply not true. The military does not let idiots work on complicated weapons systems. They may be idiots in other ways, but if they have a highly technical job, they can hardly be classified as a poor at their job.

If you have been in the military you know about this next topic. If not, then you should know that when anyone enters the military they are given a battery of tests. Yup -- they are called apptitude tests. Believe it or not, many people have apptitude for certain tasks and concepts but they have never been required to pursue it/them. They may never have turned a wrench in their life but they turn out to be excellent mechanics. They generally develop excellent diagnostic skills because their thought processes were already logical. When applied to a skill they become a natural. On the other hand, most anyone can learn from a book and pass a test but yet cannot function in that career field because they can't think logically. Those who are able to "think outside the box" are not tied to the old adage that "this is the way it was always done" and therefore that's the way must always be done. Logical thinkers are problem solvers.
 

pine island fred

Lieutenant Junior Grade
Joined
Dec 20, 2002
Messages
1,144
Re: I need some interview questions answered by a marine mechanic

SILVERTIP, not picking on the military. Am baseing my opinion on my AIR FORCE time between 63 and 67. Things might have changed but I found the military to be to specialized. In my case it was rivets and aluminum and was no way near being qualified to take the A&P exam when discharged. Will admit that the NAVY did appear to give people more leash to gain experience.
RODBOLT is a good example. EX NAVY electronics, excellent mech. but still had to do much schooling and recurent trainig to be where he is today.
Your neice should do well at RIDDLE, have to question though how deep they will let her go. Most engine build up is done by outside sources under contract by civilians. Think I am drifting off the post subject and running my mouth like I am sitting at the legion bar. regards FRED
 

nitsuj

Chief Petty Officer
Joined
Jul 22, 2003
Messages
483
Re: I need some interview questions answered by a marine mechanic

Anyone, and I repeat anyone, with "apptitude" can learn to do most anything.

Yes. I said that. Starting with the proper aptitude is key. If you're not mechanically inclined, you'll never make a good mechanic. You may get a job as a mechanic. But you'll be the type of mechanic people get on forums and tell horror stories about.

Our forefathers learned by doing because there were no text books or institutions of higher learning to teach them the things that we now take with a grain of salt.

Exactly my point. If you're good at something, the best way to be good at it is to learn by doing. If you're not good at it all the training the world won't change that. If it could, art would be worthless because any old Joe could take a learn how to draw class and turn out a masterpiece. So the art market would be flooded. And all bands would begreat because all you need to do is take some guitar lessons and you're ready to rock the stage. This isn't the case.

To make a blanket statement that the military does not offer good training is simply not true.

I think you're looking for a fight that isn't there. I never said that. Or anything like it. Please re-read my posts.

The military does not let idiots work on complicated weapons systems. They may be idiots in other ways, but if they have a highly technical job, they can hardly be classified as a poor at their job.

If you say so. But I've met plenty of bad mechanics that were trained in the military. That isn't to say the training was bad. But sometimes I think they place people in jobs they shouldn't have. They lay out manuals with step by step instructions. They make it so the people doing the jobs are able to do them. The absolute worst mechanic I had the misfortune of managing was fresh out of the Army where he worked on fighter jets. He may have been a cracker jack jet tech. But when you took away the manual and had him try to troubleshoot a difficult problem, he fell apart. It wasn't the military's lack of training at fault. He just wasn't a mechanical guy. He was properly trained. it didn't help.

If you have been in the military you know about this next topic. If not, then you should know that when anyone enters the military they are given a battery of tests. Yup -- they are called apptitude tests.

So when you join the military, they give everyone a non-running engine and let you try to figure it out? Or do they give you a written test and take the results and extrapolate that you may be good at fixing engines? We're you the one that said our forefather didn't need fancy book learning and tests to train them? Now your position is that if a military aptitude test says you're destined to be a mechanic, then you are. I'm not putting down the military here. I'm pro military. But they are not infallible. Just because a test says someone will make a good mechanic doesn't make it so. Maybe they don't have the desire? No aptitude test, no training, and not even natural ability can give someone the pride in work that the job requires in addition to the talent. Why do you think there seems to be far more bad mechanics out there than good ones? Why are forums like this one packed with boat shop horror stories? Being a good mechanic is hard. It takes skills, it takes desire, hard work, and pride. An aptitude test and some training isn't what it takes. If you think it is, you're insulting me and everyone else who has ever turned a wrench for a living. Sure, we're blue collar, and never given the respect of a lawyer or CPA, but I take pride in the fact that I'm good at it. And that not everyone can do it.

Believe it or not, many people have apptitude for certain tasks and concepts but they have never been required to pursue it/them. They may never have turned a wrench in their life but they turn out to be excellent mechanics.

A big part of my point. Chances are, if someone has the aptitude in addition to the desire and pride required, it probably wouldn't take a test at the age of 18 to find out about it. If a person has what it takes, they probably would have started on their own at a young age. Taking a test and being "required" to put it in to practice isn't how you make a good technician. Some people are born with the aptitude but don't have the interest. They're no better off that then person born without the aptitude.

They generally develop excellent diagnostic skills because their thought processes were already logical. When applied to a skill they become a natural.

Or not. Mechanical aptitude is more than a thought process. Lots of folks are very smart. And can design systems that are far about my head to comprehend. Even mechanical systems. But put tools in their hands and they're dangerous.

On the other hand, most anyone can learn from a book and pass a test but yet cannot function in that career field because they can't think logically. Those who are able to "think outside the box" are not tied to the old adage that "this is the way it was always done" and therefore that's the way must always be done. Logical thinkers are problem solvers.

I think we're really in agreement here. You seem to pretty much think the way I think on this. Our main difference is that somewhere along the line you feel I've insulted the military. I've not.
 

hambim336

Recruit
Joined
Jun 20, 2011
Messages
2
Re: I need some interview questions answered by a marine mechanic

Hi

You can find this info by using search box in the top of website with some keywords related before posting questions.

If you want to get more materials that related to this topic, you can visit: Mechanic interview questions
Best regards.
 

Bob_VT

Moderator & Unofficial iBoats Historian
Staff member
Joined
May 19, 2001
Messages
26,066
Re: I need some interview questions answered by a marine mechanic

No need to resurrect a post this old. Your response is considered HIJACKING and your previous attempt was deleted.

Welcome to iboats.

CLOSED
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top