Re: First Time Ocean Destination...opinions needed
They're both outstanding Cruising Grounds. We live in the Greater Los Angeles area, went to Puget Sound last July and I have a boat similar in size to yours, a 23 ft Dorsett Cabin Cruiser. If you can only do one, I'll vote for the Sound. It's beautiful , there's a lot to see & do and the weather is nice, except that it rains. There are many Marinas with slips plus, anchorages if you wish solitude.
I don?t think you can do justice to Catalina, Anacapa, Santa Cruz and the other Islands in a week and I don't agree with QC about the sea conditions.
Yes, it can & does get rough in the afternoon or when a storm comes thru. Pay attention to the weather forecast plus cross the Channel early. The mornings are generally good, there is an afternoon chop you can count on. If rotten conditions, such as Santa Ana Winds or a storm, are predicted hide out in a secure Cove or Marina, not on open water.
The islands have moorings and anchorages, on the weekends they can get crammed with local boaters, anything from a Kayak (Yes people cross in Kayaks) to 200 ft. There are no slips on any of the Islands, you pay for moorings and the string line (Avalon & Two Harbors). You can anchor in specified areas. You really should consider some sort of dinghy, there are shore boats at Avalon & Two Harbors, of course you pay for the ride.
There are many good coves to anchor in. Remember there is a Tide, don't Beach the Boat.