What is the Full Throttle RPM range for you engine? 4000 - 4400? 4200 - 4600? 4400- 4800? You say 4900 is what you are currently getting. So based on that, you may be over revving 100 rpms or more. A prop in the same lineage with more pitch will lower rpms, whether or not you gain any speed is maybe yes, maybe no. Drop rpms too much and you can end up going slower even with more pitch. Rule of thumb, One inch change in pitch generally results in a change of 200 rpm To add to the confusion/excitement are higher performance prop lines. These when properly matched may yield better top speed, again what works on one boat might not on another. Stainless props can be found as Heavy Duty props or very high performance props. Usually most SS are a compromise of more a bit more performance and a bit more strength.
What is your current prop, material, manufacturer and model? When I mean model, I'm not asking dia. and pitch. Black max, Vengence, Raker, Viper, Ballistic, Hustler, are models. Mercury, Qiuicksilver, Michigan, OMC/BRP. Solas, Turning point, are some manufacturers/brands.