Re: Evinrude 33 hp prop size?
Since you are loading the boat heavily, you'll want something on the order of a mid-range pitch to a lower-range pitch. The problem is that you won't know exactly how low to go on pitch, without doing some experimenting. Without a tach, you'll just be guessing, based on how high the engine seems to be revving. On the other hand, if you had a tach, you could tell exactly how high it is revving and would know if it is operating within the proper WOT range (I don't remember and can't find my 33hp service manual - I think its about 4500 - 5500) recommended by OMC.
The eventual selection will end up being a compromise, as it always is with a boat prop. In effect, you are driving a vehicle with one gear. Because of this, you have to choose a pitch (select a gear) that will meet a balance of needs - accelleration and top end. In doing so, you will optimize neither.
On the thought that a higher pitch will increase top end, that is a yes an no situation. If you run the boat with a light load, you might get more speed with a higher pitch. If you operate as you describe, you most likely won't. This is because the motor will be overloaded and will not achieve a desired rpm. What you will do in this case, is to "lug" your engine. That, in turn, will cause your motor to run at high manifold pressures, which will waste a lot of fuel and possibly damage the engine.
If my memory serves me correctly, there were 4 blade props for these motors, but I doubt you'll find a new one. If you decide to go that route, try fleabay, or a similar site.
???