Does anyone striper/white bass fish in Indiana

fireman57

Captain
Joined
Aug 24, 2004
Messages
3,811
My buddies and I have been fishing Racoon Lake by Rockville for about 10 years. Are there any other good lakes that you fish and what are your techniques? We use white and chartruese rooster tails along with a siler/chrome blue fox. Have had moderate success when we find them but have lots of time to enjoy cold ones when we can't.<br /><br />If we see any disturbance on the top we will work deep underneath them for the larger ones. Does anyone have a method for finding them when there is no action on the surface?<br /><br />Please leave Lake Michigan out as I am in extreme southwestern Indiana and the three hour drive to Rockville is as far as I want to drive. Other lakes from Indy on south would be good though.
 

NathanY

Commander
Joined
Mar 16, 2002
Messages
2,408
Re: Does anyone striper/white bass fish in Indiana

Does anyone have a method for finding them when there is no action on the surface?<br />
Invest in a good graph, an look for large schools of shad. Stripers and whites will ALWAYS be where the shad are.<br /><br />Trolling with several lines out at different depths works good too and is productive all year long.
 

fireman57

Captain
Joined
Aug 24, 2004
Messages
3,811
Re: Does anyone striper/white bass fish in Indiana

Have a good depthfinder and we do find the schools of shad with the larger shapes in them indicating striper/whites. We work these schools very diligently but with limited success. This lake is up 65 ft deep and the fish seem to suspend at 18-20ft. It is hard to catch suspended fish. We can only get our lures down to about 10 feet without a downrigger for trolling. Not going to go to that expense. It seems like the tighter the ball the better the fishing is. I guess that they ball up tighter when the fish are feeding on them. The looser the cluster the less fish. do these fish just hang around schools of shad and then all of a sudden go berzerk and start feeding or is there a pattern? these fish used to have huge jumps early and late in the day with the occasional jump in the afternoon. The last five or so years we see very few jumps at all. Does this mean that the fish are maturing and no longer feed in this type of frenzy? When they did jump they were all small fish up to around 1/4". We found that if we let the lure sink to the bottom and work it up through them we would catch the 1/2 pounder and up. If the small fish are the ones starting the jump and the larger are lurking underneath to pick up an easy meal of cripples why don't the new hatch continue jumps?
 

jtexas

Fleet Admiral
Joined
Oct 13, 2003
Messages
8,646
Re: Does anyone striper/white bass fish in Indiana

Happens a lot on the lakes here, seems to be harder to get bit by suspended fish than the ones on the bottom at 20-30 feet.<br /><br />We use slabs, like these made by one of the six old geezers on Lake Texoma:<br />www.sixoldgeezers.com/ad.htm<br /><br />I haven't tried prunepicker's, usually I find some in the tackle shop of that general shape & size. Best luck has been on chartreuse/white, also white with holographic reflective tape. Bomber Lures Slab Spoon is the only big name brand I've seen comes close to the right shape.<br /><br />Vertical presentation, just lift & let drop. Vary the pattern 'til you get bit, from big jerks, 3 or 4 feet at a time, to just barely dunking 'em. 3/4 or 1 oz. will sink about a foot per second.<br /><br />Sometimes a chrome hopkins spoon does the trick.<br /><br />Also sometimes a 4 inch sassy shad white or pearl or chartreuse on a 3/4 or 1 oz. jig head, or a 4 inch Storm wildeye swim shad, chartreuse/silver, very slow retrieve, they got a pretty good sink rate, too.<br /><br />Last but not least, if you're marking fish that aren't biting, this usually gets 'em (but not so much in the wintertime):<br /><br /> Hell Pet rig <br /><br />It's a Hellbender with hooks removed & a 3/4 oz. weight added, followed by a 4 foot leader & #12 pet spoon. Troll it at 2-3 mph 75 or 80 feet behind the boat, runs about 17 feet deep, deeper with small diameter braided line, a little less with 17 lb mono. Run it throught the school & you should hook up on every pass. If you don't, then let more line out, or vary the speed a bit. If you don't get a bite on 3 or 4 passes then move on, don't waste your time & gasoline. This is mostly effective in the spring & summer; fall & winter almost always require vertical presentation. <br /><br />Hellbender color (silver or white) doesn't seem to matter; neither does the color of the feather on the spoon. But it does seem to need to be a pet spoon. Academy Sports has a cheaper knock-off that works just as well, but the little screw holding the hook in comes out after a dozen fish or so, so now I take it out & put it back in with loc-tite. <br /><br />Some people have reported success using a DB22 in place of the hellbender, I haven't tried it. Or a 3-way swivel with a DB22 followed by a pet spoon. I mostly prefer not to troll, though, because I'd rather fight the fish than the hellbender.<br /><br />As far as finding 'em, if I notice a hump, say, 10 feet shallower than the surrounding water I'll usually stop & look for bait on the graph. If I see it I'll fish it for a little while since sometimes whites will hug the bottom so close they don't show up on the graph. Fish the edges & across the top. Same if you find a point that comes way out into the lake. <br /><br />Also, you may already know about this, but if you see a flock of birds with tailfeathers pointed at the sky, fish under 'em. Sea gulls is the bird of choice around here, but sometimes we catch 'em under pelicans or terns or water turkeys (some kind of loon-looking swimming bird that dives underwater).<br /><br />When a shad gets threatened, it tries to hide in the center of the school, so as each one tries to get to the middle they get tighter and tighter. Finally a predator will just slash through the middle, like a cue ball on the break, wounding & disorienting a bunch of 'em, which just flutter down, which explains the effectiveness of jigging a slab. I've actually watched this happen on my fishfinder, you see a sort of thumbprint with diagonal lines slashing through the middle.<br /><br />A dying shad sort of lies on the bottom attempting to swim but not getting very far, the wave action pushing it back & forth, which is what a slab barely bounced off the bottom looks like, or drifting a wildeye on the bottom.<br /><br />As far as "jumps," (we call it "schooling") that usually happens in the summertime, rarely this early in the year, but it happens every year. Sometimes if the water level gets way up they'll feed shallow without breaking the surface, makes me think maybe it's more about how far from the bottom the shad will go to get away from 'em. I know people say the bigger ones are underneath, but I'm a sucker for a big splashy topwater strike, and my fish aren't usually smaller than anybody elses. But usually anything shiny will draw a strike in a feeding frenzy.<br /><br />Long post, don't know if any of these techniques will work on your lakes, there's at least a dozen big impoundments within 100 miles of here, three of which I fish regularly, & the same stuff usually works on all of 'em. Sometimes have to vary the size or shape of the lures.<br /><br />Have fun & post your results!
 

fireman57

Captain
Joined
Aug 24, 2004
Messages
3,811
Re: Does anyone striper/white bass fish in Indiana

Great info.. I like the hellpet rig trolling for when things get slow. Should work if it runs around 17ft because our fish seem to suspend around 18. I've heard that the hopkins spoon works well but have only tried it twice. Ran out of patience. I'm like you in the fact that I like casting and fighting that fish rather than the boat dragging him to tire him out. Thanks for the links and info. Wish I was closer to Texas. We have limited opportunity for these fish here. Love the page of slabs. Must order some soon as things should start picking up here around 2nd week of May. Thanks again and will post our successes and failures. Good luck.
 

NathanY

Commander
Joined
Mar 16, 2002
Messages
2,408
Re: Does anyone striper/white bass fish in Indiana

I only use these:<br />
SlabSpoon_Family_l.jpg
<br /><br />And these:<br />
cc_spoon_group.jpg
<br /><br />The top one is Bomber Slab Spoons and the bottom is Cotton Cordell CC Spoon. Both are extremely effective for schooling and suspended fish. I like white, char., and nickel in the Bomber, and just nickel in the CC.
 

fireman57

Captain
Joined
Aug 24, 2004
Messages
3,811
Re: Does anyone striper/white bass fish in Indiana

Nate if you check out the sixoldgeezers link from jtexas they look surprisingly like you Cotton Cordell CC Spoon. I will need to order these as the local ****'s sporting goods chain and Wallyworld don't stock anything like these. We too only use silver, chartruese and sometimes blue believe it or not for these fish. No other color seems to be as effective.
 

NathanY

Commander
Joined
Mar 16, 2002
Messages
2,408
Re: Does anyone striper/white bass fish in Indiana

I get both at WalMart, but they are hard to find this time of year, so I buy them in late fall/winter.
 

fireman57

Captain
Joined
Aug 24, 2004
Messages
3,811
Re: Does anyone striper/white bass fish in Indiana

Sorry Mod that is the real name of the store. I wasn't trying to be cute or slip one by you. I've been on this forum long enough and have enough respect for it to not do things like that.
 

imported_JD__

Petty Officer 1st Class
Joined
Jun 13, 2003
Messages
243
Re: Does anyone striper/white bass fish in Indiana

One of the very best artificial baits we use on Smith Mountain Lake for Stripers here in Virginia is the Zoom Super Fluke in White pearl, Rainbow Shad & Smokin Shad colors on 3/8-5/8 oz. jig heads. Run the hook just through the nose, out the belly slit then rotate the Fluke body 180 degrees, push up on keeper barb then bring the hook out through the back. <br /><br />I have good electronics so I find the fish and jig directly beneath my transducer. I watch the fish and my lure, keeping my lure in the strike zone. Sometimes they want it ripped and other times a light finesse twitch, depends on their activity level. Water temps here are low-mid 40's. Sections of the lake that run West to East get more sun and seem to hold more bait, especially major tributaries off the main lake. Look for S-turns in the creek channels and fast breaking points and humps that stair-step all the way out to the channels. We're jigging between 25 & 50 feet deep. Works like a charm here in VA, may be way off base in Indiana.<br /> If you care to take a look, here's a couple nice schools of Striper I recorded a while back. The larger and more actively feeding fish were near the bottom. I caught and released 16 out of the .0125 school, 8-11# fish.<br /><br /> http://webpages.charter.net/abshire5078/
 

fireman57

Captain
Joined
Aug 24, 2004
Messages
3,811
Re: Does anyone striper/white bass fish in Indiana

Seems stripers everywhere like the same combinations. They have only stocked these for nine out of the last ten years in this lake so there are not as many as there should be as a lot of people when they catch one will keep it. When we catch a big one I'm sure we will release it. Keep the whites for eating. Those are some sweet pictures. I'll pick up a few Flukes and give them a try. You guys have been great on tips for catching them when they are not very active. Can't wait for the weather to break and water to warm.
 

imported_JD__

Petty Officer 1st Class
Joined
Jun 13, 2003
Messages
243
Re: Does anyone striper/white bass fish in Indiana

Oh, they're active, just not as much or as often. A lot of people wait for them to surface/break before fishing for them and some plug the banks but most are missing the jackpot because of fishing to shallow. When I caught the 16 I mentioned, after finding the school I cut my gas engine and never re-started it until I was ready to leave. I just ran my trolling motor and jigged deep covering an area about an acre in size, staying over the school.<br /><br />I personally had rather fish the cold water periods for them than Summer. They are deep enough that boats don't spook them as bad plus they don't move as far or as fast and are more concentrated. Seem to have preferred overwintering areas, travel less and are easier for me to locate. The best part of the cold water time is NO JET SKIERS!!!
 

fireman57

Captain
Joined
Aug 24, 2004
Messages
3,811
Re: Does anyone striper/white bass fish in Indiana

Man, you are right about the jet skiers. The problem with fishing this lake in the cold,not to mention it's cold, is that this lake is run by the corp of engineers and they draw it down to winter pool and the ramps don't touch the water. Winter pool is 640ft summer is 662 and capacity is 690. Right now it is at 655 which is doable but the cabin we stay in has no heat. I don't mind fishing in the chill if there is a place to warm up and I catch fish. A lot of people say that the outboard idling puts the fish down. We have never noticed any difference. This lake gets so much boat traffic as it's only one hour away from Indy that I guess they are used to it. We are definitely going to try more jigging this year after reading all you guys posts. If we can't drag them out of there with our traditional methods then we will go to jigging for sure.
 
Top