I went through this last spring, helping my son buy his first (cheap but competent) new lake/river runabout. It came down to a choice between a Bayliner Element F16 and a Tahoe T16, both at a similar price point. From close inspections, online reviews (Boat Test, etc.), and lengthy on-water trials of both boats, the Tahoe T16 was clearly the better boat.
The Tahoe was more stable in drift, tracked better at speed, handled more precisely at slow speeds, and handled chop or roiling water with less slamming. Both boats have inexpensive fittings and components, but the Tahoe's were better finished and, for example, used a minimal amount of screws v. bolts and backing. The Tahoe's hull and deck are industrially printed and seemed more consistent on inspection and more solid on the water. My son now has over a hundred hours on the Tahoe without issues.
Only an opinion, of course, although one based on research and experience with both boats. Not affiliated with either corporation. Good luck with your decision.
