Try some new plugs and see if she works again. If so, never troll with that motor again. Even if the plugs don't fix it, never troll with that motor again. Yes, I know you used brand new spark plugs but if they are Champions, 1/4 mile of trolling should be able to foul at least one of the spark plugs. As FR has stated that motor has issues with spark. It is very prone to dirty points and fouling spark plugs. For the latter, throw away any Champion spark plugs you have and replace them with NGK B7HS plugs. For some reason the NGK plugs resist fouling on that motor a little better then the Champions do. I have no idea why, I just know they do.
If it is not the plugs then check spark and if one cylinder is out it is probably a dirty set of points.
I should add, that my advice above is specific to the 1974-1976 9.9/15Hp models. Any motor after 1976 will troll all day with no complaint and Champions plugs work best in them. Unfortuneatly not your motor.