The Michigan Prop selector shows Vortex 3-Blade (992112) Vortex B 13 1/4 X 13 as one of the choices. More digging shows a Vortex C 13 pitch but only a 12 1/2 diameter.
If your engine is a long shaft(20inch) it will use the Vortex B series. If it is a short shaft (15inch) it has a smaller gearcase and would use the Vortex C series. Using the Vortex C prop on a long shaft motor will have exhaust gases flowing over the prop blades as well as going thru the prop hub, resulting in a lot of slippage.
You need to verify which version of the 75 you have, and you may very well have a prop that is physically too small for the engine.
While the WOT range for that engine is 5300 -5800, it really needs to be propped as close to 5800 rpm as possible to get the best performance, especially with a heavier boat. At 1 1/2 hp per cubic inch displacement that 3 cylinder was designed for very light and fast hulls so it's not the best choice for a 19 footer. It will have a soggy bottom end when accelerating compared to say a 85hp of the same era. But the 85hp had almost double the displacement