1st Time purchase... HELP :)

scottysize

Recruit
Thread starter
Joined
Apr 22, 2009
Messages
2
OK. I'm looking to purchase my first boat. I know I want a fish and ski because I'll be doing both. I have found two boats in my price range.

One is a 2007 - Caravelle 207 F/S 54AM - 20 ft. 4 in. with a Mercruiser 5.0 220 HP. 55.4 hours. 2007 Road Runner tandem trailer w/brakes & fold away tongue. 9 person/1275 lbs. Livewell. Removable Sundeck pads to convert for fishing chairs front and rear.

The other is a 2004 - Glastron GX 185 FS 65RB - 18 ft. 5 in. with a Volvo Penta 4.3 GL 190 hp 114 hours. 04 EX Loader trailer w/surge brakes & swing away tongue. 8 person/1200lbs Rear ladder. Swim platform. Bimini top. 23 pitch aluminum prop, and a 22 pitch SS prop.

I will have 2-4 people on board most days. My concern is that I'm a large 250lbs man. Will either of these pull me out of the water while trying to ski? I'm leaning toward the Glastron because of the features and price, but I'm scared of the V6 190hp. Even though the Caravelle is a 5.0, it's only 30hp more and the boat is a 20 footer.

Thoughts?
 

tashasdaddy

Honorary Moderator Emeritus
Joined
Nov 11, 2005
Messages
51,019
Re: 1st Time purchase... HELP :)

both good boats, if it has not been done the glasstron is nearing needing manifold, and bellows inspected, possible replacement.

both boats when were the outdrives off for service and realignment.

they are both low hour boats. fresh or salt water use???
 

Dunaruna

Admiral
Joined
May 2, 2003
Messages
6,027
Re: 1st Time purchase... HELP :)

If you are learning (2 skiis) then yes, both boats will easily pull you out of the water.
 

cbavier

Lieutenant
Joined
Apr 8, 2007
Messages
1,363
Re: 1st Time purchase... HELP :)

Both will pull you up on Ski's fine. The 5.0 will perform quicker and with more ease. But the 4.3 a lot cheaper. The 4.3 will be easier on fuel consumption, especially when just cruising and not skiing. Both have equal performance when at anchor. ;) Mine says Ten persons at 1475 Lbs but where will Ten people sit. I can only find seating for 8 and 4 better be under 100 Lbs so go figure.
 

scottysize

Recruit
Thread starter
Joined
Apr 22, 2009
Messages
2
Re: 1st Time purchase... HELP :)

Thank you very much. Wasn't sure if the 4.3 was ok or not, but it sounds like it is. It'll be an easier sale to the wife. This will be for freshwater use. I live 10 minutes from a decent size lake. (Lake Ray Roberts, if you're ever in North Texas)
 

tmh

Lieutenant Junior Grade
Joined
Aug 16, 2006
Messages
1,136
Re: 1st Time purchase... HELP :)

I'd say both of those can pull up a heavyish skier, but you may want to get the "right" prop to do it well. Until you have a boat and test WOT rpm, hole shot, etc. with existing prop it's hard to be specific, bu5t lower pitch, 4 blade SS prop will usually be better for hole shot. Maybe the 22" SS it has will be OK, you'll have to try it.

Fuel consumption.... I wouldn't even factor that in, not a big dif. Fact is, the Carvelle is a bigger boat, so yeah, uses more gas. 5.0L vs. 4.4L , nah, ot a game changer for fuel. One is carb, the other fuel inject, right? That makes some dif. on fuel.
 
Top