opinions needed please!

[neptune202]

I am looking for opinions on the following- I am trying to decide between a new 2002 Pro Line 22 Walk w/200 hp Mercury O/B or new 22 Walk Wellcraft w/ 175 Johnson. Each boat is priced and trailer about the same.

 

[fishthebay]

Re: opinions needed please!

I have a 1973 Proline. Does that tell you something? Its almost 30 years old and is still floating strong.

 

[bigbluebirdy]

Re: opinions needed please!

I have a 1990 Wellcraft Sport 20 footer. Very well-made boat. Everything on it still works, and is in great shape. I have never seen a Proline in person, so I can't make a fair call here, but my experience with Wellcraft has been great - I would buy another one. I hear others say the same thing. Obviously if you want a faster boat, then take the Proline with the 200hp Merc. Personally, I'd like the Wellcraft with the 200 Merc!!!<br /><br />Good luck. I'm sure you'll be happy with either boat. Look closely at the details of each layout and options that come with each. <br /><br />Chris

 

[neptune202]

Re: opinions needed please!

Thanks for your replys, more are welcome. I suspect most boats today are well made (hull integrity etc.). I currently own a '94 Sunbird Neptune 202 w/a 6cyl gearcase V4 Evinrude 140, which except for the VRO whistle has been a jewel. I am just ready for a little larger and newer boat. I can only buy one so your opinions are helpful. I am also adding the Lenco trolling/tabs to whatever I purchase. Any feedback on the trollers from Lenco?

 

[KCook]

Re: opinions needed please!

Remarkably similar designs. So test drive both and let that decide it. Would expect 200hp to run stronger than 175hp of course!<br /><br />Also try at www.boatus.com and www.thehulltruth.com<br /><br />Please keep us posted,<br />Kelly Cook