Looks like your prop is right in the parameters for the engine. You can check recommended propellers at the Prop Wizzard
https://turningpointpropellers.com/PROPWIZARD/ (working link below), but for this engine and similar boat it recommends either 19 pitch or 21 pitch with the right diameter. As for the nicks on the blades, if they are not too deep and the blades are not deformed, just use the file and take the nicks out, that is what the shops do.
Thank you, I used their prop wizard to get to the 4 blade hustler 19p. I was under the impression that if I have a towing propeller on for water sports and heavy loads I should reach the top of my rpm range if not exceed it under light load conditions? I thought raising the pitch decreased max rpms? I lowered pitch and my rpms went down and I was concerned about over straining the engine. I'm new to the process and I definitely don't want to cause any issues. Strange also, while testing the propeller I ended up with cavitation burn after only running for about two hours. I did ventilate once but only for about 2 seconds. Hull is clean so I'm not sure what would cause it and I didn't think it should be able to cause the prop to burn in such a short amount of time. Are there any brand preferences out there? Powertech? Michigan wheel? Quicksilver? Turning point? Thanks